Ellickson P L, Bell R M, McGuigan K
Social Policy Department, RAND, Santa Monica, CA 90407-2138.
Am J Public Health. 1993 Jun;83(6):856-61. doi: 10.2105/ajph.83.6.856.
Although several studies have reported short-term gains for drug-use prevention programs targeted at young adolescents, few have assessed the long-term effects of such programs. Such information is essential for judging how long prevention benefits last. This paper reports results over a 6-year period for a multisite randomized trial that achieved reductions in drug use during the junior high school years.
The 11-lesson curriculum, which was tested in 30 schools in eight highly diverse West Coast communities, focused on helping 7th and 8th grade students develop the motivation and skills to resist drugs. Schools were randomly assigned to treatment and control conditions. About 4000 students were assessed in grade 7 and six times thereafter through grade 12. Program effects were adjusted for pretest covariates and school effects.
Once the lessons stopped, the program's effects on drug use stopped. Effects on cognitive risk factors persisted for a longer time (many through grade 10), but were not sufficient to produce corresponding reductions in use.
It is unlikely that early prevention gains can be maintained without additional prevention efforts during high school. Future research is needed to develop and test such efforts.
尽管有几项研究报告了针对青少年的药物使用预防项目的短期成效,但很少有研究评估此类项目的长期效果。这些信息对于判断预防益处能持续多久至关重要。本文报告了一项多地点随机试验在6年期间的结果,该试验在初中阶段实现了药物使用的减少。
这一包含11节课的课程在西海岸八个高度多样化社区的30所学校进行了测试,重点是帮助七年级和八年级学生培养抵制药物的动机和技能。学校被随机分配到治疗组和对照组。约4000名学生在七年级时接受评估,此后直至十二年级又评估了六次。项目效果根据预测试协变量和学校效应进行了调整。
一旦课程结束,该项目对药物使用的影响就停止了。对认知风险因素的影响持续了更长时间(许多影响一直到十年级),但不足以使药物使用相应减少。
如果高中期间没有额外的预防措施,早期预防成效不太可能持续。未来需要开展研究来开发和测试此类措施。