Liaschenko J
School of Nursing, University of California, San Francisco.
ANS Adv Nurs Sci. 1993 Jun;15(4):71-81. doi: 10.1097/00012272-199306000-00008.
In this article the author re-examines from a feminist perspective the now well-known debate between Yarling and McElmurry and Bishop and Scudder. The central point of this critique is that a feminist ethics requires we attend to the social and institutional form of life in which given practices exist. The endorsement of a single concept, even the extremely important one of care, is insufficient for a nursing ethics. Without attention to the institutional factors, which support or reform care, we have only a feminine ethics. In this author's view, nursing needs a feminist ethics.
在本文中,作者从女性主义视角重新审视了亚林与麦克尔默里以及毕晓普与斯卡德之间那场广为人知的争论。这种批判的核心观点是,女性主义伦理学要求我们关注特定实践所存在的社会和制度生活形式。仅仅认可单一概念,即使是极其重要的关怀概念,对于护理伦理学而言也是不够的。如果不关注支持或改革关怀的制度因素,我们所拥有的就只是一种女性伦理学。在作者看来,护理需要一种女性主义伦理学。