Can ultraviolet erythema be used to identify the basal cell carcinoma phenotype?

Since a prolonged duration of a strong UVB erythema has been suggested as a marker for propensity to develop skin cancer, we objectively followed the duration and intensity of erythemas induced by UVB and UVA radiation for 28 days in 18 patients with basal cell carcinoma (BCC), and in 15 healthy controls using reflectance spectrophotometry. The erythema index, defined as the difference in redness between UV-exposed skin and normal, adjacent skin on the lower abdomen, did not differ significantly between the two groups at 24 h, when the reaction was maximal, following a dose of 6 MED of UVB. Erythema values after 7 and 14 days were slightly higher in the BCC group, but this difference did not reach statistical significance. At day 7 some patients in the BCC group showed very strong erythemas. At days 21 and 28 the two groups had almost identical erythemal reactions. Following a standard dose of UVA of 100 J/cm2, patients with BCC and healthy controls both showed weak erythemal reactions, which declined somewhat over the study period. No significant differences in pigmentary response were noted between the BCC and the control group, neither following UVB nor UVA. Although individual patients with BCC deviate from the normal erythemal curve for UVB, the UVB response is not a suitable predictive instrument in screening patients with the basal cell carcinoma phenotype.