Bakker C J, Kouwenhoven M, Hartkamp M J, Hoogeveen R M, Mali W P
Department of Radiology, University Hospital Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Magn Reson Imaging. 1995;13(7):959-65. doi: 10.1016/0730-725x(95)02005-e.
The purpose of this study was to assess the accuracy and precision of time-averaged flow as measured by nontriggered 2D PC. Mono-, bi-, and triphasic flow patterns, modelling waveforms encountered in the human vascular system, were generated by a computer-controlled flow system. Time-averaged flow velocity was measured by conventional 2D cardiac-triggered cine PC and by nontriggered 2D PC for different settings of the excitation flip angle and the velocity sensitivity. Accuracy and precision were determined by repeating the measurements (N = 6) and comparing the results against precisely known calibration values. Measurements revealed waveform-specific deviations between triggered and nontriggered acquisitions that depended on the velocity sensitivity and, more strongly, on the flip angle of the nontriggered experiment. This confirmed the theoretically predicted predominance of amplitude over phase effects. Systematic errors could be reduced by decreasing the flip angle and the velocity sensitivity, although at the expense of signal-to-noise, so that additional signal averaging was required to maintain a specified precision. The attainable accuracy appeared to be acceptable only for waveforms with a relatively low pulsatility index. The study demonstrates the feasibility of accurate and precise nontriggered velocity measurements for weakly pulsatile flow and indicates a route towards improving the reliability for highly pulsatile flow.
本研究的目的是评估非触发式二维相位对比法(2D PC)测量时间平均血流的准确性和精密度。由计算机控制的血流系统生成了模拟人体血管系统中遇到的波形的单相、双相和三相血流模式。对于不同的激发翻转角和速度灵敏度设置,通过传统的二维心脏触发电影PC和非触发式二维PC测量时间平均血流速度。通过重复测量(N = 6)并将结果与精确已知的校准值进行比较来确定准确性和精密度。测量结果显示,触发式和非触发式采集之间存在波形特异性偏差,这取决于速度灵敏度,更强烈地取决于非触发式实验的翻转角。这证实了理论上预测的幅度效应优于相位效应。通过减小翻转角和速度灵敏度可以减少系统误差,尽管这是以牺牲信噪比为代价的,因此需要额外的信号平均来维持指定的精密度。对于脉动指数相对较低的波形,可达到的准确性似乎是可以接受的。该研究证明了对弱脉动血流进行准确和精确的非触发式速度测量的可行性,并指出了提高高脉动血流可靠性的途径。