Goldstein K P, Philipson T J, Joo H, Daum R S
Department of Pediatrics, University of Chicago, IL, USA.
JAMA. 1996 Jul 3;276(1):56-8.
To evaluate whether immunization against a vaccine-preventable disease is sought to avoid the naturally occurring disease itself, we hypothesized that the rate of "on-time" measles immunization would increase during an epidemic of that disease. If such an effect occurred, we wondered whether it would have an impact on on-time administration of other recommended immunizations.
Retrospective evaluation of immunization rates of children at their second birthday with the use of computerized health records of children entering kindergarten in an 8-year interval spanning the onset of epidemic measles in Chicago, Ill, in 1989 and 1990.
Children entering Chicago public schools.
Rates of receipt of measles-containing vaccine (MCV), 1 to 4 doses of a diptheria toxoid-tetanus toxoid-pertussis (DTP) or diphtheria toxoid-tetanus toxoid (DT) vaccine, 1 to 3 doses of oral or inactivated polio vaccine (OPV/IPV), and the full series of these vaccines (4:3:1) that are required to be "up-to-date" by the second birthday.
The rate of on-time MCV receipt increased from 56% to 58% in the years prior to 70% during the epidemic (1989 and 1990). A similar increase did not occur to DTP/DT 4 or OPV/IPV 3. Moreover, among older children delayed in MCV receipt, evidence of catch-up immunization also occurred during the epidemic years; similar catch-up for delayed DTP/DT 4 or OPV/IPV 3 immunization did not occur.
Dramatic increases in one-time and catch-up MCV receipt occurred during the Chicago measles epidemic of 1989 and 1990. The lack of similar increases in DTP/DT 4 and OPV/IPV 3 suggests MCV receipt was not associated with receipt of other recommended immunizations during that time.
为评估接种疫苗预防疾病是否是为了避免自然发生的疾病本身,我们假设在某疾病流行期间,“按时”接种麻疹疫苗的比例会上升。如果出现这种效应,我们想知道这是否会对其他推荐疫苗的按时接种产生影响。
利用1989年和1990年伊利诺伊州芝加哥市麻疹流行期间8年间进入幼儿园儿童的计算机化健康记录,对儿童两岁时的免疫接种率进行回顾性评估。
进入芝加哥公立学校的儿童。
含麻疹疫苗(MCV)接种率、1至4剂白喉类毒素-破伤风类毒素-百日咳(DTP)或白喉类毒素-破伤风类毒素(DT)疫苗接种率、1至3剂口服或灭活脊髓灰质炎疫苗(OPV/IPV)接种率,以及两岁时达到“最新”要求所需的这些疫苗全系列(4:3:1)接种率。
在流行期间(1989年和1990年),按时接种MCV的比例从流行前几年的56%升至58%,在流行期间达到70%。DTP/DT 4剂或OPV/IPV 3剂接种率未出现类似上升。此外,在MCV接种延迟的大龄儿童中,流行年份也出现了补种免疫的情况;而对于延迟的DTP/DT 4剂或OPV/IPV 3剂免疫接种,未出现类似的补种情况。
1989年和1990年芝加哥麻疹流行期间,一次性和补种MCV的接种率显著上升。DTP/DT 4剂和OPV/IPV 3剂接种率未出现类似上升,这表明当时MCV接种与其他推荐疫苗接种无关。