Levine A, Pennell R I, Alvarez M E, Palmer R, Lamb C
Plant Biology Laboratory, Salk Institute for Biological Studies, La Jolla, California 92037, USA.
Curr Biol. 1996 Apr 1;6(4):427-37. doi: 10.1016/s0960-9822(02)00510-9.
Avirulent pathogens elicit a battery of plant defenses, often accompanied by collapse of the challenged cells. In soybean cells, sustained accumulation of H2O2 from an oxidative burst cues localized host cell death. Such hypersensitive cell death appears to be an active process, but little is known about the mechanisms underlying cellular collapse.
We show that H2O2 stimulates a rapid influx of Ca2+ into soybean cells, which activates a physiological cell death program resulting in the generation of large (approximately 50 kb) DNA fragments and cell corpse morphology--including cell shrinkage, plasma membrane blebbing and nuclear condensation--characteristic of apoptosis. In contrast, H2O2 induction of the cellular protectant gene glutathione S-transferase is Ca(2+)-independent. Apoptosis in soybean cells and leaf tissue was induced by avirulent Pseudomonas syringae pv. glycinea but was not observed at comparable stages of the compatible interaction with the isogenic virulent strain, which fails to elicit a hypersensitive response. Apoptosis was also observed at the onset of the hypersensitive response in Arabidopsis leaves inoculated with avirulent P. syringae pv. tomato and in tobacco cells treated with the fungal peptide cryptogein, which is involved in the induction of non-host resistance to Phytophthora cryptogea.
These observations establish a signal function for Ca2+ downstream of the oxidative burst in the activation of a physiological cell death program in soybean cells that is similar to apoptosis in animals. That the characteristic cell corpse morphology is also induced in Arabidopsis and tobacco by different avirulence signals suggests that apoptosis may prove to be a common, but not necessarily ubiquitous, feature of incompatible plant-pathogen interactions. Emerging similarities between facets of hypersensitive disease resistance and the mammalian native immune system indicate that apoptosis is a widespread defence mechanism in eukaryotes.
无毒病原体引发一系列植物防御反应,通常伴随着被攻击细胞的崩溃。在大豆细胞中,氧化爆发持续积累过氧化氢会引发局部宿主细胞死亡。这种超敏细胞死亡似乎是一个活跃的过程,但关于细胞崩溃的潜在机制知之甚少。
我们发现过氧化氢刺激钙离子快速流入大豆细胞,激活生理细胞死亡程序,导致产生大片段(约50 kb)DNA片段以及细胞尸体形态,包括细胞收缩、质膜起泡和核浓缩,这些都是细胞凋亡的特征。相比之下,过氧化氢诱导细胞保护基因谷胱甘肽S-转移酶是不依赖钙离子的。无毒丁香假单胞菌大豆致病变种可诱导大豆细胞和叶片组织发生凋亡,但在与同基因有毒菌株的亲和互作的可比阶段未观察到凋亡,有毒菌株不会引发超敏反应。在用无毒丁香假单胞菌番茄致病变种接种的拟南芥叶片的超敏反应开始时以及在用真菌肽隐地蛋白处理的烟草细胞中也观察到了凋亡,隐地蛋白参与诱导对隐地疫霉的非寄主抗性。
这些观察结果确立了钙离子在氧化爆发下游的信号功能,其可激活大豆细胞中类似于动物细胞凋亡的生理细胞死亡程序。不同无毒信号在拟南芥和烟草中也诱导出特征性的细胞尸体形态,这表明细胞凋亡可能是不亲和植物 - 病原体互作的一个共同但不一定普遍存在的特征。超敏抗病性与哺乳动物天然免疫系统之间新出现的相似性表明,细胞凋亡是真核生物中一种广泛存在的防御机制。