Champault G, Lauroy J, Guillon P, Benoit J, Rizk N, Boutelier P
Service de Chirurgie Générale et Digestive, Hôpital Jean-Verdier, Bondy, France.
Ann Chir. 1996;50(3):258-62.
99 patients, 67 of whom were female, with a mean age of 25.5 years, were admitted as emergencies between 1991 and 1992 for acute abdominal pain of unknown aetiology. The follow-up, carried out prospectively, was 100% at 1 month, 98% at 6 months, 95% at 1 year, 84% at 2 years. The patients were divided into 3 groups: group I: 42 patients only underwent investigations; group II: 31 underwent laparoscopy, and the appendix was left in place after being considered to be normal by the surgeon; group III: 26 underwent laparoscopic appendicectomy for a histologically normal appendix. For 90% of patients, the painful episode never returned. In the other cases the pain returned within one year, but there was no difference between the three groups (11.2%, 9.6%, 11.5%) (ns). The causes found at the second admission were largely genital, or rare diseases (Crohn, Spiegel hernia). 2 patients were operated for acute appendicitis, not recognized in Group I. In those who had a laparoscopy (Group II and III), the incidence of persistent pain was identical whether the appendix was considered to be normal by the operating surgeon or found to be normal histopathologically. This study suggests that: after admission for acute abdominal pain of unknown cause, the incidence of recurrence of pains is of the order of 10% within one year; the investigations carried out during the patient's admission, allowed the exclusion of serious diseases for three years; the risk of missing a true appendicitis is small (2.5%) and has no prognostic significance; the finding of a normal appendix during laparoscopy should not necessarily lead to its removal; one year follow-up is sufficient to assess the outcome of abdominal pain of unknown cause.
1991年至1992年间,99例患者因病因不明的急性腹痛作为急诊入院,其中67例为女性,平均年龄25.5岁。前瞻性随访显示,1个月时随访率为100%,6个月时为98%,1年时为95%,2年时为84%。患者分为3组:第一组:42例患者仅接受了检查;第二组:31例接受了腹腔镜检查,经外科医生判定阑尾正常后予以保留;第三组:26例因组织学检查正常的阑尾接受了腹腔镜阑尾切除术。90%的患者疼痛发作未再复发。在其他病例中,疼痛在1年内复发,但三组之间无差异(11.2%、9.6%、11.5%)(无统计学意义)。第二次入院时发现的病因主要为生殖系统疾病或罕见疾病(克罗恩病、斯皮格尔疝)。第一组中有2例患者因未被识别出的急性阑尾炎接受了手术。在接受腹腔镜检查的患者(第二组和第三组)中,无论手术医生判定阑尾正常还是组织病理学检查发现阑尾正常,持续性疼痛的发生率相同。本研究表明:因病因不明的急性腹痛入院后,1年内疼痛复发率约为10%;患者入院期间进行的检查可在3年内排除严重疾病;漏诊真正阑尾炎的风险较小(2.5%)且无预后意义;腹腔镜检查时发现阑尾正常不一定非要切除;1年的随访足以评估病因不明的腹痛的转归。