Englund J A, Piedra P A, Jewell A, Patel K, Baxter B B, Whimbey E
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas 77030, USA.
J Clin Microbiol. 1996 Jul;34(7):1649-53. doi: 10.1128/JCM.34.7.1649-1653.1996.
Although rapid antigen detection methods for the documentation of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) infections are widely used with pediatric patients, these tests have not been prospectively evaluated in immunocompromised (IC) adults. For bone marrow transplant recipients and adult patients undergoing chemotherapy for leukemia who had recent onset of respiratory symptoms, respiratory samples (combined nasal wash [NW]-throat swab [TS], endotracheal tube [ET] aspirate, or bronchoalveolar lavage [BAL] samples) were collected for simultaneous culture and rapid antigen detection with the Directigen test kit (Becton Dickinson, Cockeysville, Md.). NW specimens from hospitalized pediatric patients with suspected RSV infection were also evaluated. Viral quantitation was performed on aliquots of the original specimens. A total of 539 samples from 372 adult patients were evaluated. RSV was isolated from 56 specimens (40 NW-TS, 7 ET aspirate, and 9 BAL specimens). By using culture as the "gold standard," rapid antigen detection had a sensitivity of 15% for adult NW-TS specimens, 71.4% for ET aspirate specimens, and 88.9% for BAL specimens; the specificity was > or = 97% for all specimen types. Significantly greater viral quantities were present in pediatric NW specimens than in adult NW specimens. In adults, more virus was present in BAL and ET aspirate specimens than in NW-TS specimens. Rapid detection of antigen respiratory samples obtained from the lower respiratory tracts of IC adults is sensitive and specific, but detection in upper respiratory tract samples is insensitive. The lower sensitivity of antigen detection in NW-TS specimens may be due to decreased viral load. A BAL specimen is more sensitive than an NW-TS specimen for the rapid diagnosis of RSV disease in IC adults.
尽管用于记录呼吸道合胞病毒(RSV)感染的快速抗原检测方法在儿科患者中广泛使用,但这些检测方法尚未在免疫功能低下(IC)的成人中进行前瞻性评估。对于近期出现呼吸道症状的骨髓移植受者和接受白血病化疗的成年患者,采集呼吸道样本(联合鼻洗液[NW]-咽拭子[TS]、气管内插管[ET]吸出物或支气管肺泡灌洗[BAL]样本)用于同时进行培养和使用Directigen检测试剂盒(Becton Dickinson,Cockeysville,Md.)进行快速抗原检测。还对疑似RSV感染的住院儿科患者的NW标本进行了评估。对原始标本的等分试样进行病毒定量。共评估了来自372名成年患者的539份样本。从56份标本中分离出RSV(40份NW-TS、7份ET吸出物和9份BAL标本)。以培养作为“金标准”,快速抗原检测对成人NW-TS标本的敏感性为15%,对ET吸出物标本为71.4%,对BAL标本为88.9%;所有标本类型的特异性均≥97%。儿科NW标本中的病毒量明显高于成人NW标本。在成人中,BAL和ET吸出物标本中的病毒比NW-TS标本中的更多。从IC成人下呼吸道获得的呼吸道样本中抗原的快速检测具有敏感性和特异性,但在上呼吸道样本中的检测不敏感。NW-TS标本中抗原检测的较低敏感性可能是由于病毒载量降低。对于IC成人中RSV疾病的快速诊断,BAL标本比NW-TS标本更敏感。