Karas B E, Conrad K M
Zurich American Insurance, Chicago, IL, USA.
AAOHN J. 1996 Apr;44(4):189-96.
The purpose of this integrative review is to describe the state of knowledge about the effect of worksite back injury prevention programs on selected study outcomes. Fifteen experimental and quasi-experimental studies published between 1987 and 1994 were identified through a comprehensive literature search. The research studies were reviewed and analyzed using a data collection abstracting tool. Four types of back injury prevention intervention programs were identified: back belts, back schools, exercise/flexibility training, and educational classes. Positive program outcomes were reported for all four program types; however, the back school and the exercise/flexibility training programs were studied more frequently and demonstrated a greater proportion of positive results than the other two program types. Conclusions should be viewed cautiously due to the small number of studies reviewed and their methodological limitations. Implications for occupational health nursing practice and future research related to worksite back injury prevention are offered.
本整合性综述的目的是描述有关工作场所背部损伤预防计划对选定研究结果影响的知识现状。通过全面的文献检索,确定了1987年至1994年间发表的15项实验性和准实验性研究。使用数据收集摘要工具对这些研究进行了审查和分析。确定了四种类型的背部损伤预防干预计划:背带、背部学校、运动/柔韧性训练和教育课程。所有四种计划类型均报告了积极的计划结果;然而,与其他两种计划类型相比,背部学校和运动/柔韧性训练计划的研究更为频繁,且显示出更高比例的积极结果。由于所审查的研究数量较少及其方法学局限性,应谨慎看待这些结论。本文还提供了对职业健康护理实践的启示以及与工作场所背部损伤预防相关的未来研究方向。