Kamiguchi H, Shiobara R, Toya S
Department of Neurosurgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan.
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 1996 May;98(2):171-5. doi: 10.1016/0303-8467(96)00016-9.
The clinical records of 1,155 patients with 1,159 brain tumors who drained on Keio University Hospital between 1983 and 1994 were reviewed. Apparently asymptomatic patients and those whose complaints or neurological deficits were not caused by the brain tumors were defined as accidental cases. For example, patients with a headache which was considered to be unrelated to the presence of a tumor were included in this series. One hundred and ten (9.5%) of the 1,155 cases were found to be accidental. Since three accidental cases had multiple meningiomas, there were 113 accidental brain tumors which involved 63 meningiomas, 22 pituitary adenomas, 9 gliomas, 7 metastatic carcinomas. 5 acoustic neurinomas and 7 miscellaneous. Meningiomas occurred significantly more frequent than other types of accidentally identified tumors. Convexity meningiomas and falx meningiomas accounted for 53.9% of the accidental meningiomas, whereas parasagittal meningiomas were less frequent. It is of note that three out of four cases with multiple meningiomas were accidental. Comparison between the present results and the previously reported incidence of asymptomatic brain tumors in postmortem studies suggest that a substantial number of pituitary adenomas, acoustic neurinomas and small parasagittal meningiomas without suggestive symptoms are likely to be missed by routine neuroradiological examinations.
回顾了1983年至1994年间在庆应义塾大学医院引流的1155例患有1159个脑肿瘤患者的临床记录。明显无症状的患者以及那些主诉或神经功能缺损并非由脑肿瘤引起的患者被定义为意外病例。例如,本系列纳入了那些被认为头痛与肿瘤存在无关的患者。在1155例病例中,有110例(9.5%)被发现是意外情况。由于3例意外病例患有多发脑膜瘤,因此共有113个意外脑肿瘤,其中包括63个脑膜瘤、22个垂体腺瘤、9个胶质瘤、7个转移癌、5个听神经瘤和7个其他肿瘤。脑膜瘤的发生明显比其他类型的意外发现肿瘤更为频繁。大脑凸面脑膜瘤和镰旁脑膜瘤占意外脑膜瘤的53.9%,而矢状窦旁脑膜瘤则较少见。值得注意的是,4例多发脑膜瘤病例中有3例是意外情况。将本研究结果与先前尸检研究中报告的无症状脑肿瘤发病率进行比较表明,常规神经放射学检查可能会遗漏大量无提示症状的垂体腺瘤、听神经瘤和小矢状窦旁脑膜瘤。