Nuti A, Lucetti C, Pavese N, Dell'Agnello G, Rossi G, Bonuccelli U
Institute of Clinical Neurology, University of Pisa, Italy.
Cephalalgia. 1996 Aug;16(5):337-40. doi: 10.1046/j.1468-2982.1996.1605337.x.
Various open and controlled studies have confirmed the antimigraine action of flunarizine, while the antimigraine properties of nimodipine are still open to controversy. Moreover, only a few studies include an additional follow-up after discontinuation of migraine prophylaxis with either drug. We carried out a single blind evaluation of the efficacy and tolerance of flunarizine (25 patients) in comparison with nimodipine (25 patients) and the long-term effect after discontinuation of a 6-month treatment. Both medications significantly reduced migraine frequently and severity. Flunarizine was more efficacious than nimodipine in reducing migraine frequency (p < 0.001), pain severity (p < 0.05), migraine index (p < 0.05) and corrected migraine index (p < 0.05). The positive effect lasted 8.4 +/- 4.0 months after discontinuation of flunarizine and 4.9 +/- 3.5 months after nimodipine (p < 0.05). Our results suggest that flunarizine is more effective than nimodipine in the prophylactic treatment of migraine. The positive effect after drug discontinuation lasts longer with flunarizine, compared to nimodipine.
多项开放性和对照性研究已证实氟桂利嗪的抗偏头痛作用,而尼莫地平的抗偏头痛特性仍存在争议。此外,只有少数研究包括在停用这两种药物的偏头痛预防性治疗后进行额外的随访。我们对氟桂利嗪(25例患者)与尼莫地平(25例患者)的疗效和耐受性进行了单盲评估,并对6个月治疗停药后的长期效果进行了评估。两种药物均能显著降低偏头痛的发作频率和严重程度。在降低偏头痛发作频率(p<0.001)、疼痛严重程度(p<0.05)、偏头痛指数(p<0.05)和校正偏头痛指数(p<0.05)方面,氟桂利嗪比尼莫地平更有效。停用氟桂利嗪后,积极效果持续8.4±4.0个月,停用尼莫地平后为4.9±3.5个月(p<0.05)。我们的结果表明,在偏头痛的预防性治疗中,氟桂利嗪比尼莫地平更有效。与尼莫地平相比,停用氟桂利嗪后积极效果持续时间更长。