Shaheen S O, Aaby P, Hall A J, Barker D J, Heyes C B, Shiell A W, Goudiaby A
MRC Environmental Epidemiology Unit, University of Southampton, Southampton General Hospital.
BMJ. 1996 Oct 19;313(7063):969-74. doi: 10.1136/bmj.313.7063.969.
To investigate whether children who have had measles have reduced general cell mediated immunity three years later compared with vaccinated children who have not had measles.
Historical cohort study.
Bissau, Guinea-Bissau.
391 children aged 3-13 years who were living in Bissau during a measles epidemic in 1991 and still lived there. These included 131 primary cases and 139 secondary cases from the epidemic and 121 vaccinated controls with no history of measles.
General cell mediated immunity assessed by measurement of delayed type hypersensitivity skin responses to seven recall antigens. Anergy was defined as a lack of response to all antigens.
82 out of 268 cases of measles (31%) were anergic compared with 20 of the 121 vaccinated controls (17%) (odds ratio adjusted for potential confounding variables 2.2 (95% confidence interval 1.2 to 4.0); P 0.009). The prevalence of anergy was higher in secondary cases (33% (46/138)) than in primary cases (28% (36/130)), although this difference was not significant. Anergy was more common in the rainy season (unadjusted prevalence 31% (91/291) than in the dry season (11% (11/98)) (adjusted odds ratio 4.8 (2.2 to 10.3)). This seasonal increase occurred predominantly in the case of measles.
Reduced general cell mediated immunity may contribute to the higher long term mortality in children who have had measles compared with recipients of standard measles vaccine and to the higher child mortality in the rainy season in west Africa.
调查出过麻疹的儿童在三年后与未出过麻疹的接种疫苗儿童相比,其总体细胞介导免疫是否降低。
历史性队列研究。
几内亚比绍的比绍。
1991年麻疹流行期间居住在比绍且仍居住在该地的391名3至13岁儿童。其中包括该次流行中的131例原发病例和139例继发病例,以及121名无麻疹病史的接种疫苗对照儿童。
通过测量对七种回忆抗原的迟发型超敏皮肤反应来评估总体细胞介导免疫。无反应性定义为对所有抗原均无反应。
268例麻疹病例中有82例(31%)无反应,而121名接种疫苗对照儿童中有20例(17%)无反应(经潜在混杂变量调整后的优势比为2.2(95%置信区间1.2至4.0);P = 0.009)。继发病例的无反应性患病率(33%(46/138))高于原发病例(28%(36/130)),尽管这种差异不显著。无反应性在雨季更为常见(未调整患病率31%(91/291)),高于旱季(11%(11/98))(调整后的优势比为4.8(2.2至10.3))。这种季节性增加主要发生在麻疹病例中。
总体细胞介导免疫降低可能是出过麻疹的儿童与标准麻疹疫苗接种者相比长期死亡率较高以及西非雨季儿童死亡率较高的原因。