Is pathology examination of disc specimens necessary after routine anterior cervical discectomy and fusion?

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective chart review was performed from 1990-1994.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the outcome of pathologic examination of cervical disc specimens submitted after anterior cervical discectomy.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

This study is the first to review the outcome of pathologic examination of disc specimens after anterior cervical discectomy and fusion.

METHODS

Charts were reviewed based on the procedure code of anterior cervical fusion and the main diagnoses of cervical disc and spondylosis. The following data were recorded for each patient: symptoms, examination, diagnostic studies, operative procedure, operative findings, and pathology report. Statistical analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Five hundred six disc levels in 394 patients were reviewed. All patients had symptoms and examination results consistent with cervical radiculopathy. All patients had cervical radiographs and some combination of myelography, computed tomography, or magnetic resonance imaging. Findings at the time of surgery included the presence of either a herniated disc or degenerative spondylitic changes. The pathologic examination results of all specimens reported fibrocartilaginous tissue consistent with disc material with the presence of degenerative changes. No infectious, benign, or malignant process was identified at the time of surgery or on gross and histologic examination of any of the disc specimens. Using confidence intervals (95%) for exact proportions and given 500 negatives, the chance the next occurrence would be positive would be 0.0060 or 0.60% or six of 1000.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that if the symptoms, physical examination, radiographic diagnostic studies, and surgical findings are consistent with those of cervical disc herniation of spondylosis, the chance of an unexpected, clinically important pathologic finding within the disc specimen is extremely small. The time and expense involved in routine pathologic examination of cervical disc specimens can be avoided.