Belli R, De Benedictis M, Varbella F, Castello V, Baduini G
Divisione di Cardiologia, Ospedale Mauriziano Umberto I, Torino.
G Ital Cardiol. 1996 Jul;26(7):765-74.
Percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (POBA) of complex lesions is hindered by a lower success rate and a higher risk of complications. New devices are now available for treatment of this type of lesions (type B-C of the modified AHA/ACC classification). We present our experience in the treatment of calcified, ostial, angled and long coronary lesions by means of percutaneous transluminal coronary rotational ablation (PTCRA, Rotablator Heart Technology, Bellevue, Washington).
From June 1991 to November 1995 we performed 71 procedures of rotational atherectomy on 72 lesions in 62 patients. Twenty-three patients presented stable angina, 30 patients unstable angina and 9 silent myocardial ischemia. Thirty-five patients had single, 16 double and 11 triple vessel coronary artery disease. Left ventricular mean ejection fraction was 58 +/- 8%. The lesions attempted were classified as type A in 2 cases, B1 in 23 cases, B2 in 31 cases and C in 16 cases according to the AHA/ACC modified classification. Calcifications detected at coronary angiography were present in 66 lesions; 53 lesions were longer than 10 mm; 12 were more than 45 degrees angulated; 9 were at a bifurcation site and 3 were ostial in location. The vessels treated were in 1 case a protected Left Main Trunk, in 40 the Left Anterior Descending, in 9 the Circumflex and in 22 the Right Coronary Artery. We did not treat lesions containing visible thrombus or located on old saphenous vein grafts because of the high risk of peripheral embolization. An average of 2 +/- 1 burrs was used; the mean burr/vessel diameter ratio was 0.59 +/- .07. "Complementary" low pressure PTCA was performed in all but 4 cases ("stand alone procedure").
Primary success was obtained in 62/71 procedures (92%) and in 67/72 lesions (94%). There were two major cardiac events during the hospital stay: one death and one acute myocardial infarction which occurred respectively at four days and 48 hours after the procedure due to late occlusion of the vessel treated with primary success. In three cases the procedure was unsuccessful but uncomplicated: In one the stenosis could not be crossed, in a second case a residual stenosis > 50% was present, in a third case the procedure resulted in dissection and occlusion of a vessel served by good intercoronary collaterals. No emergency or elective coronary artery bypass surgery was necessary. Coronary spasm occurred in 6 cases (9%). In two of them spasm was refractory to intracoronary nitrates and Verapamil, and stent implantation was required. Urapidil, a selective alpha 1 blocker, completely abolished the occurrence of coronary vasospasm in the last 16 cases. A no reflow phenomenon was observed in two cases associated with mild CK-MB elevation. In conclusions: our experience suggests that rotational atherectomy performed on lesions with complex morphology, most of them calcified, is a safe and effective procedure which therefore can be undertaken even in hospitals without on site cardiac surgery. Our data on late restenosis are inconclusive because of the lack of angiographic follow up.
复杂病变的经皮腔内冠状动脉成形术(PTCA)成功率较低且并发症风险较高,这阻碍了其应用。现在有了新的设备可用于治疗这类病变(改良的美国心脏协会/美国心脏病学会分类中的B - C型)。我们介绍我们通过经皮腔内冠状动脉旋磨术(PTCRA,Rotablator心脏技术,华盛顿州贝尔维尤)治疗钙化、开口处、成角及长冠状动脉病变的经验。
1991年6月至1995年11月,我们对62例患者的72处病变进行了71例旋磨术。23例患者表现为稳定型心绞痛,30例为不稳定型心绞痛,9例为无症状性心肌缺血。35例患者为单支冠状动脉病变,16例为双支病变,11例为三支病变。左心室平均射血分数为58±8%。根据美国心脏协会/美国心脏病学会改良分类,所尝试治疗的病变中,2例为A型,23例为B1型,31例为B2型,16例为C型。冠状动脉造影检测到钙化的病变有66处;53处病变长度超过10毫米;12处成角超过45度;9处位于分叉部位,3处位于开口处。所治疗的血管中,1例为受保护的左主干,40例为左前降支,9例为回旋支,22例为右冠状动脉。由于外周栓塞风险高,我们未治疗含有可见血栓或位于陈旧大隐静脉移植血管上的病变。平均使用2±1个磨头;磨头/血管直径平均比值为0.59±0.07。除4例(“单纯手术”)外,所有病例均进行了“补充性”低压PTCA。
71例手术中有62例(92%)、72处病变中有67处(94%)获得了初次成功。住院期间发生了两例主要心脏事件:1例死亡和1例急性心肌梗死,分别在手术成功治疗的血管发生晚期闭塞后4天和48小时出现。3例手术未成功但无并发症:1例无法穿过狭窄部位,第2例存在残余狭窄>50%,第3例手术导致一支有良好冠状动脉侧支循环供血的血管发生夹层和闭塞。无需进行急诊或择期冠状动脉搭桥手术。6例(9%)发生冠状动脉痉挛。其中2例对冠状动脉内硝酸酯类和维拉帕米难治,需要植入支架。选择性α1受体阻滞剂乌拉地尔在最后16例中完全消除了冠状动脉痉挛的发生。2例观察到无复流现象,伴有轻度肌酸激酶同工酶(CK - MB)升高。结论:我们的经验表明,对形态复杂(大多数为钙化)的病变进行旋磨术是一种安全有效的手术,因此即使在没有现场心脏外科手术的医院也可进行。由于缺乏血管造影随访,我们关于晚期再狭窄的数据尚无定论。