Messori A, Bonistalli L, Costantini M, Alterini R
Drug Information Centre, Azienda Ospedaliera Careggi, Florence, Italy.
Bone Marrow Transplant. 1997 Feb;19(3):275-81. doi: 10.1038/sj.bmt.1700642.
The analysis of published survival curves can be used as the basis for conducting cost-effectiveness analyses in which two treatments are compared in terms of cost per life year saved. In patients with relapsed chemosensitive non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT) has been reported to improve survival in comparison with control patients who receive standard chemotherapy. An incremental cost-effectiveness analysis was undertaken in which the Gompertz model was used to determine a lifetime estimate of patient-years gained by subjects given ABMT in comparison with controls. Our study utilised the cost data calculated by Uyl-de Groot et al and the clinical data reported by Philip et al. This latter randomised clinical trial involved 55 patients subjected to ABMT and 54 controls given chemotherapy. Lifetime survival advantage for patients of the ABMT group was estimated as 3606 discounted patient-months every 100 patients. The use of ABMT as opposed to standard chemotherapy was found to imply an incremental cost of $9,229 per discounted life year gained (95% CI of $5,390 to $24,012). The cost-effectiveness ratio of ABMT in patients with relapsed chemosensitive non-Hodgkin's lymphoma is noticeably favourable.
已发表生存曲线的分析可作为进行成本效益分析的基础,在成本效益分析中,可根据挽救每生命年的成本对两种治疗方法进行比较。在复发性化疗敏感非霍奇金淋巴瘤患者中,据报道,与接受标准化疗的对照患者相比,自体骨髓移植(ABMT)可提高生存率。进行了一项增量成本效益分析,其中使用Gompertz模型来确定接受ABMT的受试者与对照组相比获得的患者年数的终生估计值。我们的研究利用了Uyl-de Groot等人计算的成本数据以及Philip等人报告的临床数据。后一项随机临床试验涉及55例接受ABMT的患者和54例接受化疗的对照。ABMT组患者的终生生存优势估计为每100例患者3606个贴现患者月。与标准化疗相比,使用ABMT意味着每获得一个贴现生命年的增量成本为9229美元(95%可信区间为5390美元至24012美元)。ABMT在复发性化疗敏感非霍奇金淋巴瘤患者中的成本效益比明显有利。