Grimm R H, Grandits G A, Prineas R J, McDonald R H, Lewis C E, Flack J M, Yunis C, Svendsen K, Liebson P R, Elmer P J
Shapiro Center for Evidence-Based Medicine, Minneapolis Medical Research Foundation, MN 55404, USA.
Hypertension. 1997 Jan;29(1 Pt 1):8-14. doi: 10.1161/01.hyp.29.1.8.
Problems with sexual function have been a long-standing concern in the treatment of hypertension and may influence the choice of treatment regimens and decisions to discontinue drugs. The Treatment of Mild Hypertension Study (TOMHS) provides an excellent opportunity for examination of sexual function and effects of treatment on sexual function in men and women with stage I diastolic hypertension because of the number of drug classes studied, the double-blind study design, and the long-term follow-up. TOMHS was a double-blind, randomized controlled trial of 902 hypertensive individuals (557 men, 345 women), aged 45 to 69 years, treated with placebo or one of five active drugs (acebutolol, amlodipine maleate, chlorthalidone, doxazosin maleate, or enalapril maleate). All participants received intensive lifestyle counseling regarding weight loss, dietary sodium reduction, alcohol reduction (for current drinkers), and increased physical activity. Sexual function was ascertained by physician interviews at baseline and annually during follow-up. At baseline, 14.4% of men and 4.9% of women reported a problems with sexual function. In men, 12.2% had problems obtaining and/or maintaining an erection; 2.0% of women reported a problem having an orgasm. Erection problems in men at baseline were positively related to age, systolic pressure, and previous antihypertensive drug use. The incidences of erection dysfunction during follow-up in men were 9.5% and 14.7% through 24 and 48 months, respectively, and were related to type of antihypertensive therapy. Participants randomized to chlorthalidone reported a significantly higher incidence of erection problems through 24 months than participants randomized to placebo (17.1% versus 8.1%, P = .025). Incidence rates through 48 months were more similar among treatment groups than at 24 months, with nonsignificant differences between the chlorthalidone and placebo groups. Incidence was lowest in the doxazosin group but was not significantly different from the placebo group. Incidence for acebutolol, amlodipine, and enalapril groups was similar to that in the placebo group. In many cases, erection dysfunction did not require withdrawal of medication. Disappearance of erection problems among men with problems at baseline was common in all groups but greatest in the doxazosin group. Incidence of reported sexual problems in women was low in all treatment groups. In conclusion, long-term incidence of erection problems in treated hypertensive men is relatively low but is higher with chlorthalidone treatment. Effects of erection dysfunction with chlorthalidone appear relatively early and are often tolerable, and new occurrences after 2 years are unlikely. The rate of reported sexual problems in hypertensive women is low and does not appear to differ by type of drug. Similar incidence rates of erection dysfunction in placebo and most active drug groups caution against routine attribution of erection problems to antihypertensive medication.
性功能问题一直是高血压治疗中备受关注的问题,可能会影响治疗方案的选择以及停药决策。轻度高血压治疗研究(TOMHS)为研究I期舒张期高血压男性和女性的性功能以及治疗对性功能的影响提供了绝佳机会,这是因为该研究涉及多种药物类别、采用双盲研究设计且进行了长期随访。TOMHS是一项针对902名年龄在45至69岁的高血压患者(557名男性,345名女性)的双盲随机对照试验,这些患者接受安慰剂或五种活性药物(醋丁洛尔、马来酸氨氯地平、氯噻酮、马来酸多沙唑嗪或马来酸依那普利)之一的治疗。所有参与者都接受了关于减肥、减少饮食中的钠摄入、减少饮酒(针对当前饮酒者)以及增加体育活动的强化生活方式咨询。通过医生在基线时的访谈以及随访期间每年的访谈来确定性功能情况。在基线时,14.4%的男性和4.9%的女性报告存在性功能问题。在男性中,12.2%存在勃起功能障碍;2.0%的女性报告存在性高潮问题。男性在基线时的勃起问题与年龄、收缩压以及既往使用抗高血压药物有关。男性在随访期间勃起功能障碍的发生率在24个月和48个月时分别为9.5%和14.7%,并且与抗高血压治疗的类型有关。随机分配接受氯噻酮治疗的参与者在24个月内报告的勃起问题发生率显著高于随机分配接受安慰剂治疗的参与者(17.1%对8.1%,P = 0.025)。48个月时各治疗组之间的发生率比24个月时更为相似,氯噻酮组和安慰剂组之间无显著差异。多沙唑嗪组的发生率最低,但与安慰剂组无显著差异。醋丁洛尔、氨氯地平和依那普利组的发生率与安慰剂组相似。在许多情况下,勃起功能障碍并不需要停药。基线时存在问题的男性中勃起问题消失在所有组中都很常见,但在多沙唑嗪组中最为明显。所有治疗组中女性报告的性问题发生率都很低。总之,接受治疗的高血压男性勃起问题的长期发生率相对较低,但氯噻酮治疗时发生率较高。氯噻酮导致的勃起功能障碍效应出现相对较早,且通常可以耐受,2年后新出现的情况不太可能发生。高血压女性报告的性问题发生率较低,且似乎不因药物类型而异。安慰剂组和大多数活性药物组中勃起功能障碍的发生率相似,这提醒人们不要将勃起问题常规归因于抗高血压药物。