Grimm R H, Grandits G A, Cutler J A, Stewart A L, McDonald R H, Svendsen K, Prineas R J, Liebson P R
Department of Medicine, School of Medicine, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, USA.
Arch Intern Med. 1997 Mar 24;157(6):638-48.
To compare 5 antihypertensive drugs and placebo for changes in quality of life (QL). To assess the relationship of lifestyle factors and change in lifestyle factors to QL in participants with stage I diastolic hypertension.
The Treatment of Mild Hypertension Study (TOMHS) was a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial with minimum participant follow-up of 4 years. It was conducted at 4 hypertension screening and treatment academic centers in the United States. The cohort consisted of 902 men and women with hypertension, aged 45 to 69 years, with diastolic blood pressures less than 100 mm Hg. Informed consent was obtained from each participant after the nature of the procedures had been fully explained. Sustained nutritional-hygienic intervention was administered to all participants to reduce weight, to reduce dietary sodium and alcohol intake, and to increase physical activity. Participants were randomized to take (1) acebutolol (n = 132); (2) amlodipine maleate (n = 131); (3) chlorthalidone (n = 126); (4) doxazosin mesylate (n = 134); (5) enalapril maleate (n = 135); or placebo (n = 234). Changes in 7 QL indexes were assessed based on a 35-item questionnaire: (1) general health; (2) energy or fatigue; (3) mental health; (4) general functioning; (5) satisfaction with physical abilities; (6) social functioning; and (7) social contacts.
At baseline, higher QL was associated with older age, more physical activity, lower obesity level, male gender, non-African American race, and higher educational level. Improvements in QL were observed in all randomized groups, including the placebo group during follow-up; greater improvements were observed in the acebutolol and chlorthalidone groups and were evident throughout follow-up. The amount of weight loss, increase in physical activity, and level of attained blood pressure control during follow-up were related to greater improvements in QL.
In patients with stage I hypertension, antihypertensive treatment with any of 5 agents used in TOMHS does not impair QL. The diuretic chlorthali-done and the cardioselective beta-blocker acebutolol appear to improve QL the most. Success with lifestyle changes affecting weight loss and increase in physical activity relate to greater improvements in QL and show that these interventions, in addition to contributing to blood pressure control, have positive effects on the general well-being of the individual.
比较5种抗高血压药物及安慰剂对生活质量(QL)的影响。评估I期舒张期高血压患者生活方式因素及其变化与生活质量的关系。
轻度高血压治疗研究(TOMHS)是一项随机、双盲、安慰剂对照的临床试验,参与者最少随访4年。该研究在美国4个高血压筛查与治疗学术中心进行。队列由902名年龄在45至69岁、舒张压低于100 mmHg的高血压男性和女性组成。在向每位参与者充分解释程序性质后获得了知情同意。对所有参与者进行持续的营养卫生干预,以减轻体重、减少饮食中的钠和酒精摄入量并增加身体活动。参与者被随机分为服用(1)醋丁洛尔(n = 132);(2)马来酸氨氯地平(n = 131);(3)氯噻酮(n = 126);(4)甲磺酸多沙唑嗪(n = 134);(5)马来酸依那普利(n = 135);或安慰剂(n = 234)。基于一份35项问卷评估7个生活质量指标的变化:(1)总体健康状况;(2)精力或疲劳程度;(3)心理健康状况;(4)总体功能;(5)对身体能力的满意度;(6)社交功能;(7)社交接触。
在基线时,较高的生活质量与年龄较大、身体活动较多、肥胖程度较低、男性、非非裔美国人种族以及教育水平较高相关。在所有随机分组的组中均观察到生活质量有所改善,包括随访期间的安慰剂组;在醋丁洛尔和氯噻酮组中观察到更大的改善,且在整个随访期间都很明显。随访期间体重减轻的量、身体活动的增加以及血压控制水平与生活质量的更大改善有关。
在I期高血压患者中,TOMHS中使用的5种药物中的任何一种进行抗高血压治疗均不会损害生活质量。利尿剂氯噻酮和心脏选择性β受体阻滞剂醋丁洛尔似乎对生活质量的改善最为明显。影响体重减轻和身体活动增加的生活方式改变取得成功与生活质量的更大改善相关,表明这些干预措施除有助于控制血压外,还对个体的总体健康有积极影响。