Sahai A, Bélair M, Gianfelice D, Coté S, Gratton J, Lahaie R
Department of Gastroenterology, Hôpital St. Luc, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Am J Gastroenterol. 1997 Feb;92(2):275-8.
To determine whether percutaneous drainage of Crohn's abscesses obviates the need for early surgical drainage.
All cases of percutaneous drainage of Crohn's abscesses between 1990 and 1995 were reviewed and classified as a success or failure on the basis of the need for surgery within < 30 days of catheter removal.
Twenty-seven drainage procedures were performed in 24 patients; 15 (56%) were classified as successes, and 12 (44%) were classified as failures. Successes and failures did not significantly differ with respect to patient demographics and Crohn's disease characteristics. Patients whose abscesses were successfully drained had significantly fewer associated fistulae (46.6 vs 92.0%, p = 0.037), and their abscesses tended more often to be first (vs recurrent), spontaneous (vs postoperative), located in the right lower quadrant, and smaller. Patients whose abscesses were successfully drained also tended to spend more time with the catheter in place and to require more imaging procedures. Complications were noted in four cases (15%), enterocutaneous fistula at the site of catheter insertion in three cases and postprocedure fever in one case. Hospital stay was significantly shorter after successful drainage (16.3 +/- 6.9 vs 31.7 +/- 22.1 days, p = 0.017). After a total of 543.5 patient-months of follow-up, subsequent intra-abdominal Crohn's-related surgery was required in only two of the successes and one failure.
确定克罗恩病脓肿的经皮引流是否可避免早期手术引流的必要性。
回顾1990年至1995年间所有克罗恩病脓肿经皮引流的病例,并根据拔管后<30天内是否需要手术将其分类为成功或失败。
24例患者共进行了27次引流手术;15例(56%)被分类为成功,12例(44%)被分类为失败。成功组和失败组在患者人口统计学和克罗恩病特征方面无显著差异。脓肿成功引流的患者相关瘘管明显较少(46.6%对92.0%,p = 0.037),且其脓肿更常为首次(而非复发性)、自发性(而非术后性)、位于右下腹且较小。脓肿成功引流的患者导管留置时间也往往更长,且需要更多的影像学检查。4例(15%)出现并发症,3例为导管插入部位的肠皮肤瘘,1例为术后发热。成功引流后住院时间明显缩短(16.3±6.9天对31.7±22.1天,p = 0.017)。经过总共543.5个患者月的随访,仅2例成功患者和1例失败患者需要随后进行腹腔内与克罗恩病相关的手术。
1)克罗恩病脓肿的经皮引流在约50%的病例中成功避免了早期手术的必要性,且这种益处长期随访中得以维持。2)经皮引流缩短了住院时间。3)不同部位、单发或多发、有无相关瘘管的克罗恩病脓肿均可经皮成功引流。4)存在相关瘘管可能是失败的危险因素。