Frank C
Department of Medicine and Family Medicine, Queen's University, Kingston, Ont.
Can Fam Physician. 1997 Feb;43:259-65.
To review the evidence on the effectiveness of medical management of bowel obstruction for patients with advanced cancer and to summarize treatment options for home and hospital care.
Articles were identified by searching MEDLINE.
Research articles published between 1973 and 1995 on the surgical and medical management of bowel obstruction in patients with advanced cancer were identified. Seven original research articles on medical management were identified and all were reviewed and critically appraised. Given the small number of original papers in this field, studies using prospective and retrospective methodology were included. Articles looking only at the use of percutaneous gastrostomy tubes and subcutaneous hydration were used in the formulation of treatment recommendations but were not critically reviewed. A critical appraisal of the surgical literature was not undertaken.
Recommendations regarding medical management of bowel obstruction were based on strength of evidence for improving symptoms with pharmacologic treatment. The few clinical trials were uncontrolled trials with small samples. The trials show improvement of symptom control with pharmacologic management using morphine, anticholinergics, major tranquilizers, corticosteroids, and somatostatin analogues. Intravenous hydration was unnecessary for most patients. Percutaneous gastrostomy tubes are effective for patients with proximal intestinal obstruction and intractable vomiting.
Pharmacologic management and percutaneous gastrostomy for intractable vomiting and hypodermoclysis or oral fluids for hydration can control symptoms without surgery or nasogastric tubes.
回顾晚期癌症患者肠梗阻药物治疗有效性的证据,并总结家庭和医院护理的治疗选择。
通过检索MEDLINE识别文章。
识别1973年至1995年间发表的关于晚期癌症患者肠梗阻手术和药物治疗的研究文章。识别出7篇关于药物治疗的原创研究文章,并对所有文章进行了综述和严格评估。鉴于该领域原创论文数量较少,纳入了采用前瞻性和回顾性方法的研究。仅关注经皮胃造瘘管使用和皮下补液的文章用于制定治疗建议,但未进行严格审查。未对外科文献进行严格评估。
关于肠梗阻药物治疗的建议基于药物治疗改善症状的证据强度。少数临床试验为小样本无对照试验。试验表明,使用吗啡、抗胆碱能药物、主要镇静剂、皮质类固醇和生长抑素类似物进行药物治疗可改善症状控制。大多数患者无需静脉补液。经皮胃造瘘管对近端肠梗阻和顽固性呕吐患者有效。
药物治疗和经皮胃造瘘术治疗顽固性呕吐,皮下输液或口服补液用于补充水分,无需手术或鼻胃管即可控制症状。