Rømsing J, Hertel S A, Møller-Sonnergaard J, Brunbjerg J, Skyttebo M, Rasmussen M
Ore-naese-hals-afdelingen, Amtssygehuset Roskilde.
Ugeskr Laeger. 1997 Jan 20;159(4):422-5.
Several predominantly North American studies indicate that postoperative pain experienced by children is underestimated by the nurses, who are in charge of the analgesic treatment of the children's pain. The purpose of this investigation was to examine, in Danish children, the relationship between the children's ratings of their pain and the nurses' ratings of the children's pain. The issue was examined by comparing the pain ratings of 100 children three to 15 years of age following tonsillectomy. The ratings were obtained by using the Poker Chip Tool and a 10-cm Visual analogue scale. The differences between the children's and the nurses' pain ratings were most pronounced after administration of analgesics (p < 0.001). After analgesics, the children's mean pain score was 17% lower than before analgesics, while the nurses' mean pain scores of the children's pain were 53-58% lower than before analgesics. Consistent with results from foreign studies, this Danish study found that, in general, the nurses underestimated the children's pain. The nurses tended to overestimate the effect of analgesics and tended to modify their pain ratings according to the children's level of activity.
几项主要来自北美的研究表明,负责儿童疼痛镇痛治疗的护士低估了儿童术后的疼痛。本调查的目的是研究丹麦儿童对自身疼痛的评分与护士对儿童疼痛的评分之间的关系。通过比较100名3至15岁扁桃体切除术后儿童的疼痛评分来研究该问题。评分采用扑克筹码工具和10厘米视觉模拟量表获得。在给予镇痛药后,儿童与护士的疼痛评分差异最为显著(p < 0.001)。给予镇痛药后,儿童的平均疼痛评分比用药前低17%,而护士对儿童疼痛的平均评分比用药前低53 - 58%。与国外研究结果一致,这项丹麦研究发现,总体而言,护士低估了儿童的疼痛。护士往往高估了镇痛药的效果,并倾向于根据儿童的活动水平调整他们对疼痛的评分。