Laure P
J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 1996 Dec;36(4):291-2.
To document the high-level athletes' impressions of their preparticipation examination (PE).
Prospective study by self-reporting questionnaire.
One hundred-fifty French athletes, involved in national or international-level events (PE is obligatory every year in France). Response rate obtained was 71%. Subject population consisted of 107 normal, healthy, elite athletes, ranging in age from 16 to 31 years (mean 22.4 years), included 69 males and 38 females.
Knowledge and impression of PE, based upon the athletes' own experience. All of the consulted physician were trained and qualified in sports medicine.
Thirty-six percent of the athletes reported having had bad-quality preparticipation sports visit (no significant difference between gender or age). According to them, medical history taking was "poor", and physical examination "restricted to blood pressure measurement" and/or "chest listening" and "not targeted enough on past athletic injuries". Athletes said PE should especially evaluate the cardiovascular system (75% of all citations to the item), the musculoskeletal system (16%) and the lungs (8%), and should involve an electrocardiogram (41%).
Challenges for the future: 1) better educate physician in sport, to improve the preventive aspects of sports medicine 2) physicians should provide information to coaches and athletes concerning the optimal balance between health and physical performance, and therefore to the interest of PE.
记录高水平运动员对其参赛前检查(PE)的看法。
通过自我报告问卷进行前瞻性研究。
150名法国运动员,参加国家或国际级赛事(在法国每年参赛前检查是强制性的)。获得的回复率为71%。研究对象包括107名正常、健康的精英运动员,年龄在16至31岁之间(平均22.4岁),其中男性69名,女性38名。
基于运动员自身经历的对参赛前检查的认知和看法。所有咨询的医生均接受过运动医学培训并具备相应资质。
36%的运动员报告称参赛前的运动检查质量不佳(性别和年龄之间无显著差异)。据他们所说,病史采集“较差”,体格检查“仅限于测量血压”和/或“胸部听诊”,且“对既往运动损伤的针对性不足”。运动员表示,参赛前检查应特别评估心血管系统(该项目所有提及内容的75%)、肌肉骨骼系统(16%)和肺部(8%),并且应进行心电图检查(41%)。
未来的挑战:1)更好地对运动领域的医生进行教育,以改善运动医学的预防方面;2)医生应向教练和运动员提供有关健康与身体表现之间最佳平衡的信息,从而提高参赛前检查的重要性。