Illum P
ENT Department, Viborg County Hospital, Denmark.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 1997;254 Suppl 1:S89-92. doi: 10.1007/BF02439733.
In patients with septal deviation, compensatory inferior turbinate hypertrophy in the side of the nose opposite the major septal deviation is often found. Although turbinectomy in connection with septoplasty is a relatively common clinical procedure, the effectiveness of the procedure is unknown, and the indications and technique applied vary considerably. Fifty patients with nasal obstruction and anterior septal deviations responded to a questionnaire 5 years after operation. Thirty-seven of these patients were available for objective examinations and acoustic rhinometry. In connection with their operations patients had been randomized into two groups. Septoplasty was performed in one group, while the other had a septoplasty supplemented with an anterior inferior turbinoplasty performed on the side opposite the major septal deviation. The subjective overall evaluation was not influenced by turbinoplasty, and no changes in the frequency of crusting were found. In all, 24% of the patients were dissatisfied with the results of surgery, and only 43% were completely satisfied with final results. No influence of turbinate reduction was detectable. Acoustic rhinometry also showed, that there was still a marked difference between the dimensions of the two sides of the nose, and that postoperative spatial conditions were still decreased on both sides when compared with normal controls.
在鼻中隔偏曲患者中,常可发现鼻中隔主要偏曲侧对侧鼻腔的代偿性下鼻甲肥大。尽管在鼻中隔成形术的同时行鼻甲切除术是一种相对常见的临床操作,但该手术的有效性尚不清楚,且应用的适应证和技术差异很大。50例患有鼻塞和鼻中隔前部偏曲的患者在术后5年对一份问卷进行了回应。其中37例患者可进行客观检查和声反射鼻测量。在手术过程中,患者被随机分为两组。一组行鼻中隔成形术,而另一组在鼻中隔成形术的基础上,在鼻中隔主要偏曲侧的对侧行前下鼻甲成形术。主观总体评价不受鼻甲成形术的影响,且未发现结痂频率有变化。总体而言,24%的患者对手术结果不满意,只有43%的患者对最终结果完全满意。未检测到鼻甲缩小的影响。声反射鼻测量还显示,两侧鼻腔尺寸仍存在明显差异,与正常对照组相比,术后两侧鼻腔的空间条件仍有所降低。