Zimmerman M, Lush D T, Farber N J, Hartung J, Plescia G, Kuzma M A, Lish J
Rhode Island Hospital, Department of Psychiatry, Providence 02903, USA.
Int J Psychiatry Med. 1996;26(4):431-41. doi: 10.2190/8KRC-FJLB-UCGA-6CAQ.
The authors examined whether there is empirical support for the notion that medical patients are upset by being asked questions about psychiatric disorders.
Six hundred and one patients attending a primary care clinic completed the SCREENER-a newly developed, brief self-administered questionnaire that surveys a broad range of psychopathology. In addition, they completed a second questionnaire that assessed their attitudes toward the SCREENER.
We found a high level of acceptance by patients. The questions were judged easy to answer, and they rarely aroused significant negative affect. Fewer than 2 percent of the patients judged the questions difficult to answer, and fewer than 3 percent were "very much" embarrassed, upset, annoyed, or uncomfortable with the questions. Individuals with a history of psychiatric treatment and poorer current mental health reacted more unfavorably to the questionnaire.
From the patient's perspective, it is feasible and acceptable to use self-administered questionnaires for routine screening of psychiatric problems in primary care settings.
作者探讨是否有实证支持以下观点,即内科患者会因被问及有关精神障碍的问题而感到不安。
601名到初级保健诊所就诊的患者完成了“筛查问卷”——一种新开发的、简短的自我填写问卷,该问卷可对广泛的精神病理学问题进行调查。此外,他们还完成了另一份问卷,以评估他们对“筛查问卷”的态度。
我们发现患者的接受度很高。这些问题被认为易于回答,很少引起明显的负面影响。不到2%的患者认为问题难以回答,不到3%的患者对这些问题“非常”感到尴尬、不安、恼怒或不适。有精神科治疗史且当前心理健康状况较差的个体对问卷的反应更为不利。
从患者的角度来看,在初级保健机构中使用自我填写问卷进行精神问题的常规筛查是可行且可接受的。