Panhuysen C I, Vonk J M, Koëter G H, Schouten J P, van Altena R, Bleecker E R, Postma D S
University of Maryland, Baltimore, USA.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1997 Apr;155(4):1267-72. doi: 10.1164/ajrccm.155.4.9105065.
The present study investigated the outcome of asthma in a population of 181 adult patients 13 to 44 yr of age (median, 24 yr) who were extensively tested between 1962 and 1970 and in whom asthma was diagnosed. When retested 25 yr later, 38 subjects (21%) did not show bronchial hyperresponsiveness (BHR)(PC20 > 16 mg/ml), 45 subjects (25%) showed a FEV1 > 90% predicted, and 72 subjects (40%) did not report pulmonary symptoms. When absence of asthma was defined as no BHR, FEV1 > 90% predicted, and the absence of pulmonary symptoms reported by the patient, 20 subjects (11%) were no longer considered asthmatic when retested. Absence of asthma after 25 yr was associated with a younger age and less severe airway obstruction at first testing, odds ratios (OR) being 0.36 for age/10 yr, and 1.42 for FEV1/height2 (dl/m2). Absence of BHR was associated with a younger age, a higher FEV1, and a shorter untreated period (years between onset of asthma symptoms and specialized treatment of the disease) at first testing, and a lower total serum IgE level (IU/L) at second testing (OR, 0.48 for age/10 yr; OR, 1.37 for FEV1/height2; OR, 0.93 for untreated period; OR, 0.33 for log [IgE]). Neither sex nor atopy (one or more positive skin tests) were significant determinants of the outcome of both asthma and BHR. Our results suggest that in a substantial proportion of symptomatic asthmatics the disease improved, and that subsets may outgrow their asthma, even in adulthood. The data lend indirect support to the hypothesis that milder disease and earlier intervention are important for a beneficial outcome of asthma.
本研究调查了181名年龄在13至44岁(中位数为24岁)的成年哮喘患者的病情转归。这些患者在1962年至1970年间接受了全面检查,并被诊断为哮喘。25年后再次检测时,38名受试者(21%)未表现出支气管高反应性(BHR)(PC20>16mg/ml),45名受试者(25%)的第一秒用力呼气容积(FEV1)>预测值的90%,72名受试者(40%)未报告肺部症状。当将无哮喘定义为无BHR、FEV1>预测值的90%且患者未报告肺部症状时,20名受试者(11%)在再次检测时不再被视为哮喘患者。25年后无哮喘与初次检测时年龄较小和气道阻塞较轻有关,年龄每增加10岁的比值比(OR)为0.36,FEV1/身高²(dl/m²)的OR为1.42。无BHR与初次检测时年龄较小、FEV1较高、未治疗时间较短(哮喘症状发作至疾病专科治疗之间的年数)以及再次检测时总血清免疫球蛋白E(IgE)水平较低(IU/L)有关(年龄每增加10岁的OR为0.48;FEV1/身高²的OR为1.37;未治疗时间的OR为0.93;log[IgE]的OR为0.33)。性别和特应性(一个或多个皮肤试验阳性)均不是哮喘和BHR病情转归的显著决定因素。我们的结果表明,在相当一部分有症状的哮喘患者中,病情有所改善,并且即使在成年期,部分患者的哮喘也可能自愈。这些数据间接支持了以下假设,即病情较轻和早期干预对哮喘的良好转归很重要。