Leonard J C, Ellsbury K E
University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, USA.
Acad Med. 1996 May;71(5):502-4. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199605000-00023.
While increasing proportions of medical students and residents are women, the proportion of women in the advanced ranks of medicine remains small. This study describes gender differences among residents concerning interest in academic medicine and related influences.
A survey instrument was mailed to all 308 first- and third-year residents at the University of Washington School of Medicine in the late summer of 1993. The survey assessed interest in academic careers, values, psychological traits, exposure to mentoring, and perceived role stress. Frequency analysis and chi-square analysis were performed to compare the distribution responses by gender within the entire respondent group and within the first-year and third-year subgroups.
A total of 180 (58%) of all first- and third-year residents responded; 99 (55%) were men. Although the level of interest in academic careers was similar among first-year male and female residents, the level of interest was greater among third-year men than among third-year women. Women overall were less likely to consider it personally important to achieve national recognition. Women in the third (but not the first) year of residency were significantly less likely than men to agree that leading others was personally important to them. Women reported feeling less confident, were less likely to have identified a faculty member who had successfully balanced career and personal life, and were significantly more likely to feel under stress and to have interrupted their careers for childbearing.
The interest in academic careers appeared to be lower among third-year female residents than among third-year male residents, despite the similar interests in academic medicine among male and female first-year residents. Increasing role stress among women in training may explain the reduced interest in leadership and academic careers among women at more advanced levels of training.
虽然医学院学生和住院医师中女性的比例在不断增加,但医学高级职位中女性的比例仍然很小。本研究描述了住院医师在学术医学兴趣及相关影响方面的性别差异。
1993年夏末,一份调查问卷被邮寄给华盛顿大学医学院的所有308名一年级和三年级住院医师。该调查评估了对学术职业的兴趣、价值观、心理特质、接受指导的情况以及感知到的角色压力。进行频率分析和卡方分析,以比较整个受访者群体以及一年级和三年级子群体中按性别划分的回答分布情况。
所有一年级和三年级住院医师中共有180人(58%)回复;99人(55%)为男性。虽然一年级男女住院医师对学术职业的兴趣水平相似,但三年级男性的兴趣水平高于三年级女性。总体而言,女性不太可能认为获得全国认可是个人重要的事情。住院医师三年级(而非一年级)的女性比男性明显更不可能认同领导他人对自己个人很重要。女性报告称信心较低,不太可能找到一位成功平衡职业和个人生活的教员,并且明显更有可能感到压力大以及因生育而中断职业生涯。
尽管一年级男女住院医师对学术医学的兴趣相似,但三年级女性住院医师对学术职业的兴趣似乎低于三年级男性住院医师。培训中女性角色压力的增加可能解释了在更高培训阶段女性对领导和学术职业的兴趣降低的原因。