Elvin A, Sundström C, Larsson S G, Lindgren P G
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University Hospital, Uppsala, Sweden.
Acta Radiol. 1997 May;38(3):376-80. doi: 10.1080/02841859709172087.
To establish the role of ultrasound-guided cutting-needle biopsy in the diagnostic-work-up of tumours in the head and neck region.
Seventy-two patients (74 biopsies) with tumours in the head and neck were biopsied by means of a biopsy gun fitted with a 1.2-mm biopsy needle (midsized-needle biopsy, MNB). Twenty-four biopsies were taken from salivary glands, 29 from lymph nodes, and 21 from miscellaneous locations. Thirty-three of the patients were biopsied by MNB under ultrasound guidance after a blinded fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) was considered non-diagnostic or non-representative.
In 91% of the cases, the MNB diagnosis was identical to the final diagnosis (surgical or radiological/clinical follow-up: at least 6 months), 9% were false-negative/ non-representative. In 17/33 patients MNB was considered to provide more diagnostic information than FNAB, the methods had equal accuracy in 12 patients, and in 4 patients the information already gained with FNAB was superior to that provided by MNB. The non-diagnostic sampling rate for FNAB was 25% versus 3% for MNB. In 26 patients with malignant lymphoma, MNB results were diagnostically correct in all but 2 cases. FNAB was correct in 2 of 9 cases. There were no biopsy-related complications.
MNB was found to be safe and to possess a high degree of diagnostic accuracy, and could therefore, particularly in patients with lymphoma, be considered a diagnostic alternative to FNAB.
确立超声引导下切割针活检在头颈部肿瘤诊断检查中的作用。
72例头颈部肿瘤患者(74次活检)采用配备1.2毫米活检针的活检枪进行活检(中型针活检,MNB)。24次活检取自唾液腺,29次取自淋巴结,21次取自其他部位。在细针穿刺抽吸活检(FNAB)结果为非诊断性或不具代表性后,33例患者在超声引导下进行了MNB活检。
91%的病例中,MNB诊断与最终诊断(手术或放射学/临床随访:至少6个月)一致,9%为假阴性/不具代表性。在17/33例患者中,MNB被认为比FNAB提供了更多诊断信息,12例患者中两种方法准确性相同,4例患者中FNAB获得的信息优于MNB。FNAB的非诊断性采样率为25%,而MNB为3%。在26例恶性淋巴瘤患者中,除2例病例外,MNB结果在诊断上均正确。FNAB在9例中的2例中正确。未发生与活检相关的并发症。
发现MNB安全且具有高度诊断准确性,因此,特别是对于淋巴瘤患者,可被视为FNAB的一种诊断替代方法。