Wilcock A, Kobayashi L, Murray I
Department of Consumer Studies, University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada.
J Perinat Neonatal Nurs. 1997 Mar;10(4):36-47. doi: 10.1097/00005237-199703000-00012.
The North American literature on obstetric patient satisfaction of the past 25 years was reviewed using two major computerized databases. The articles identified by these searches were supplemented with other research articles identified in reference lists. The review highlights the difficulties inherent in the use of many different methodologies to study obstetric patient satisfaction. The main methodologies have been mailed questionnaires, telephone interviews, and semistructured interviews, with data collection periods ranging from 24 hours to 2 years postpartum. The various approaches to data collection make comparison of results among studies exceedingly difficult. The reluctance of patients to criticize their caregivers has been problematic and is evidenced by satisfaction ratings that are positively skewed. Factors that have been reported to be most influential in obstetric patient satisfaction include communication, control, participation in decision making, presence of a support person, information/prenatal classes, nursing care services, length of stay, and physical environment. The relative importance of these factors, however, has not been ascertained.
我们使用两个主要的计算机化数据库对过去25年北美有关产科患者满意度的文献进行了综述。通过这些检索确定的文章,又补充了参考文献列表中确定的其他研究文章。该综述突出了使用多种不同方法研究产科患者满意度所固有的困难。主要方法有邮寄问卷、电话访谈和半结构化访谈,数据收集期从产后24小时至2年不等。各种数据收集方法使得研究之间的结果比较极其困难。患者不愿批评其护理人员一直是个问题,这从呈正偏态的满意度评分中可见一斑。据报道,对产科患者满意度最具影响力的因素包括沟通、控制权、参与决策、有支持人员陪伴、信息/产前课程、护理服务、住院时间和物理环境。然而,这些因素的相对重要性尚未确定。