Kellett M W, Smith D F, Baker G A, Chadwick D W
The Walton Centre for Neurology and Neurosurgery, Liverpool.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1997 Jul;63(1):52-8. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.63.1.52.
To assess the relation between seizure status and quality of life after surgery for drug resistant epilepsy, using a previously validated quality of life model developed for use in epilepsy.
A retrospective postal survey was made on 94 patients who underwent surgery for epilepsy between 1986 and 1994, and 36 patients who after investigation during the same period were found to be unsuitable for surgery. A health related quality of life model was used containing validated measures of anxiety, depression, self esteem, mastery, impact of epilepsy, affect balance, stigma, overall health status, and overall quality of life, to examine the relation between postoperative seizure status and quality of life.
Overall 47.9% of patients were seizure free after surgery. On all measures seizure free patients scored significantly better than either patients deemed unsuitable for surgery or those having more than 10 seizures per year after surgery. Patients having less than 10 seizures per year obtained intermediate scores. There was no difference between the groups unsuitable for surgery or having more than 10 seizures per year postoperatively. Employment rates were significantly different between groups, 80% of seizure free and 53% of patients having less than 10 seizures per year in gainful employment postoperatively, compared with 28% and 27% of patients having greater than 10 seizures per year or those who were unsuitable for surgery.
Within broad categories, postoperative quality of life is clearly related to seizure outcome, but the study emphasises the importance of long term follow up in defining the tangible psychosocial effects of freedom from seizures.
运用先前验证过的适用于癫痫的生活质量模型,评估耐药性癫痫手术后癫痫发作状态与生活质量之间的关系。
对1986年至1994年间接受癫痫手术的94例患者以及同期经检查发现不适合手术的36例患者进行回顾性邮寄调查。采用一个与健康相关的生活质量模型,该模型包含焦虑、抑郁、自尊、掌控感、癫痫影响、情感平衡、耻辱感、总体健康状况和总体生活质量等经过验证的指标,以检验术后癫痫发作状态与生活质量之间的关系。
总体而言,47.9%的患者术后无癫痫发作。在所有指标上,无癫痫发作的患者得分显著高于被认为不适合手术的患者或术后每年癫痫发作超过10次的患者。每年癫痫发作少于10次的患者得分处于中间水平。不适合手术的组与术后每年癫痫发作超过10次的组之间没有差异。各组的就业率有显著差异,术后无癫痫发作的患者中有80%以及每年癫痫发作少于10次的患者中有53%从事有报酬工作,而每年癫痫发作超过10次的患者或不适合手术的患者中这一比例分别为28%和27%。
在大致分类中,术后生活质量显然与癫痫发作结果相关,但该研究强调了长期随访在确定摆脱癫痫发作所带来的切实社会心理影响方面的重要性。