White T L, Treisman M
Department of Experimental Psychology, University of Oxford, UK.
Br J Psychol. 1997 Aug;88 ( Pt 3):459-72. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8295.1997.tb02651.x.
The claim that there is no olfactory short-term memory store, as olfactory serial position (SP) effects are absent (Engen, 1987, 1989; Lawless & Engen, 1977), raises the issue whether memory for sensory qualities is differently organized from memories for more cognitive materials in vision and hearing. Early memory processing in olfaction is re-examined by comparing the results of similarly designed experiments which examine short-term memory for words and consonants, and for odours. Memory for content and memory for order were separately examined in each case. Serial position functions were obtained both for visually presented verbal materials and for odours. The serial position effects for content and order memory in both modalities are sufficiently similar in pattern to support the conclusion that short-term memory processing of olfactory and verbal stimuli is conducted by analogous memory mechanisms.
由于不存在嗅觉系列位置(SP)效应(恩根,1987年、1989年;劳利斯和恩根,1977年),因此有人声称不存在嗅觉短期记忆存储,这就引发了一个问题,即感觉性质的记忆与视觉和听觉中更多认知材料的记忆在组织方式上是否不同。通过比较设计相似的实验结果来重新审视嗅觉中的早期记忆处理,这些实验分别考察了对单词、辅音和气味的短期记忆。在每种情况下,分别考察了内容记忆和顺序记忆。分别获得了视觉呈现的语言材料和气味的系列位置函数。两种模态下内容和顺序记忆的系列位置效应在模式上足够相似,以支持嗅觉和语言刺激的短期记忆处理是由类似的记忆机制进行的这一结论。