Vaal M, van der Wal J T, Hermens J, Hoekstra J
National Institute of Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands.
Chemosphere. 1997 Sep;35(6):1291-309. doi: 10.1016/s0045-6535(97)00166-5.
Our aim in this study was to identify groups of species showing a similar pattern in their sensitivity to toxicants and to relate the patterns to the mode of toxic action and biological species characteristics. A data matrix was composed of acute toxicity data for 26 aquatic species and 21 compounds. Most of the variation in the toxicological data was due to differences in toxicity of compounds and not intrinsic differences between species, so that practically every species can be used to order compounds with respect to average toxicity. Compounds with high overall toxicity also had large interspecies variation in sensitivity. The toxicity of non-polar narcotics correlated well with the log Kow. Compounds with a specific or reactive mode of action were more than a factor 10 toxic than predicted by their log Kow. Patterns in species sensitivity were more diffuse because only part of the variance in species sensitivity could be explained. Fishes and amphibians were more sensitive to dieldrin, lindane and pentachlorophenol than were invertebrates. Among the arthropods, the Phyllopoda (daphnids) were the most sensitive species. They were very sensitive to aniline, the heavy metals, malathion and parathion.
