Barreto S M, Swerdlow A J, Smith P G, Higgins C D
Departamento de Epidemiologia e Antropologia Medica, Centro de Pesquisa Rene Rachou, Fiocruz, Belo Horizonte, Brazil.
Occup Environ Med. 1997 Aug;54(8):599-604. doi: 10.1136/oem.54.8.599.
To estimate the relative risk of death from work related injury in a steelworks, associated with exposure to various occupational hazards, sociodemographic factors, and medical history.
The study was a nested case-control design. It was based on a cohort of men employed in the steel plant of USIMINAS, Brazil between January 1977 and August 1990, who were followed up to November 1992. The cases were defined as all workers in the cohort who died from injury in the study period and whose death had been notified to the Brazilian Ministry of Labour as being related to work. Four controls per case, matched to cases on year of birth, were randomly selected from among workers employed in the plant at the time of death of the matching case. Data on potential risk factors for occupational injury were extracted from company records; for the controls these data were abstracted for the period preceding the death of the matching case.
There were 37 deaths related to work injuries during the study period. Four surviving workers were selected as controls for each case, but for eight the personnel records were incomplete, leaving 140 controls in all. Significantly increased risk of fatal injury related to work was associated with exposure to noise, heat, dust and fumes, gases and vapours, rotating shift work, being a manual worker, and working in the steel mill, coke ovens, blast furnaces, and energy and water supply areas. Risk of fatal injury related to work increased with intensity of exposure to noise (P (trend) = 0.004) and heat (P < 0.001), and increased greatly with a hazard score that combined information on noise, heat, dust, and gas exposure (P < 0.001). Number of years of schooling (P = 0.03) and salary level (P = 0.03) were both negatively associated with risk. In a multivariate analysis including all these significant factors, only hazard score and area of work remained associated with death from injury related to work. The highest risks were for men exposed to all four environmental hazards (odds ratio (OR) 19.4; 95% confidence interval (95% CI) 1.1 to 352.1) and those working in the energy supply area (OR 18.0; 1.6 to 198.1).
The study identified parts of the steelworks and types of hazard associated with greatly increased risk of fatal accident. Research and measures to prevent accidents need to concentrate on these areas and the people working in them. The use of a hazard score was successful in identifying high risk, and similar scoring might prove useful in other industrial situations.
评估某钢铁厂与接触各种职业危害、社会人口学因素及病史相关的工伤死亡相对风险。
本研究采用巢式病例对照设计。研究对象为1977年1月至1990年8月在巴西USIMINAS钢铁厂工作的男性队列,随访至1992年11月。病例定义为该队列中在研究期间死于工伤且其死亡已通知巴西劳工部与工作相关的所有工人。每例病例随机选取4名对照,对照与病例按出生年份匹配,从匹配病例死亡时该厂在职的工人中选取。职业伤害潜在风险因素的数据从公司记录中提取;对照的数据则从匹配病例死亡前的时间段提取。
研究期间有37例与工伤相关的死亡。每例病例选取4名存活工人作为对照,但有8名对照的人事记录不完整,最终共有140名对照。与工伤相关的致命伤害风险显著增加与接触噪声、热、粉尘和烟雾、气体和蒸气、轮班工作、为体力劳动者以及在炼钢厂、焦炉、高炉以及能源和供水区域工作有关。与工伤相关的致命伤害风险随噪声(P(趋势)=0.004)和热(P<0.001)暴露强度增加而增加,并且随结合噪声、热、粉尘和气体暴露信息的危害评分大幅增加(P<0.001)。受教育年限(P=0.03)和薪资水平(P=0.03)均与风险呈负相关。在纳入所有这些显著因素的多变量分析中,只有危害评分和工作区域仍与工伤死亡相关。风险最高的是接触所有四种环境危害的男性(优势比(OR)19.4;95%置信区间(95%CI)1.1至352.1)以及在能源供应区域工作的男性(OR 18.0;1.6至198.1)。
该研究确定了钢铁厂中与致命事故风险大幅增加相关的部分区域和危害类型。预防事故的研究和措施需要集中在这些区域以及在这些区域工作的人员身上。使用危害评分成功识别了高风险,类似的评分在其他工业环境中可能也有用。