Rispens J, Aleman A, Goudena P P
Department of Education, Utrecht University, The Netherlands.
Child Abuse Negl. 1997 Oct;21(10):975-87. doi: 10.1016/s0145-2134(97)00058-6.
The aim of this article was to provide data about the effects of child sexual abuse prevention programs. A more specific aim was to estimate the contribution of potential moderator variables such as age, program duration, or sample size to effect size.
A meta-analytic approach was used to calculate post-test and follow-up effect sizes of 16 evaluation studies of school programs aimed at the prevention of child sexual abuse victimization. Tests of categorical models were used in the analysis of moderator variables. Multiple regression analysis was used to determine their association with effect sizes.
Significant and considerable mean post-intervention (d = .71) and follow-up (d = .62) effect sizes were found, indicating that victimization prevention programs are successful in teaching children sexual abuse concepts and self-protection skills. Intervention characteristics such as duration and content of the program, and child characteristics such as age and SES were important moderators of effect size.
Our findings corroborate and refine the positive conclusions of traditional narrative reviews. Programs that focus on skill training, allowing sufficient time for children to integrate self-protection skills into their cognitive repertoire, are to be preferred. Future evaluation research should focus on transfer of training.
本文旨在提供有关儿童性虐待预防项目效果的数据。一个更具体的目的是评估年龄、项目时长或样本量等潜在调节变量对效应大小的影响。
采用荟萃分析方法计算了16项旨在预防儿童遭受性虐待的学校项目评估研究的后测和随访效应大小。在调节变量分析中使用了分类模型检验。采用多元回归分析来确定它们与效应大小的关联。
发现干预后(d = 0.71)和随访(d = 0.62)的平均效应大小显著且可观,表明预防受害项目在教授儿童性虐待概念和自我保护技能方面是成功的。项目的时长和内容等干预特征,以及年龄和社会经济地位等儿童特征是效应大小的重要调节因素。
我们的研究结果证实并完善了传统叙述性综述的积极结论。应优先选择注重技能培训、让儿童有足够时间将自我保护技能融入其认知体系的项目。未来的评估研究应侧重于培训的迁移。