Tal A, Miklich D R
Psychosom Med. 1976 May-Jun;38(3):190-200. doi: 10.1097/00006842-197605000-00005.
This study found that vividly remembered incidents of intense anger and similarly recalled fear decreased 1-sec forced expiratory flow rates (FEV1)in 35 male and 25 female chronic asthmatic children who had no psychopathology. FEV1 increased with relaxation. Changes in FEV1 following anger correlated with changes following fear as highly as the reliabilities of the responses permitted, although anger produced a greater decrease than fear. FEV1 decrease following anger and fear correlated with FEV1 increase due to relaxation. The amount of change in each of the three conditions correlated with history of emotionally precipitated asthma. This pattern was interpreted to mean that the same phenomenon underlies emotional-bronchoconstriction, relaxation-bronchodilitation, and emotionally triggered asthma. No relationship was found between degree of allergic sensitivity (atopy) and FEV1 changes in any of the three conditions nor did atopy correlate with history of emotionally triggered asthma. These results do not support the view that psychological and allergic factors are inversely related, alternative causes of asthma.
本研究发现,在35名男性和25名女性无精神病理学问题的慢性哮喘儿童中,清晰回忆起的强烈愤怒事件以及类似回忆起的恐惧会降低1秒用力呼气流量(FEV1)。FEV1随着放松而增加。愤怒后FEV1的变化与恐惧后FEV1的变化高度相关,达到了反应可靠性所允许的程度,尽管愤怒导致的下降比恐惧更大。愤怒和恐惧后FEV1的下降与放松导致的FEV1增加相关。这三种情况中每种情况的变化量都与情绪诱发哮喘的病史相关。这种模式被解释为意味着情绪性支气管收缩、放松性支气管扩张和情绪触发哮喘背后存在相同的现象。在这三种情况中的任何一种情况下,均未发现过敏敏感性(特应性)程度与FEV1变化之间存在关联,特应性也与情绪触发哮喘的病史无关。这些结果不支持心理因素和过敏因素是哮喘的反向相关替代原因这一观点。