De Agostini M, Khamis A H, Ahui A M, Dellatolas G
INSERM U169, Villejuif, France.
Brain Cogn. 1997 Nov;35(2):151-67. doi: 10.1006/brcg.1997.0935.
In order to examine further the role of cultural and environmental factors in human manual preference, two surveys were undertaken in students from Ivory Coast and Sudan. In the first study (Abidjan, Ivory Coast) 382 secondary students, ages 12 to 22, answered a 20-item manual preference questionnaire. The observed frequency of left-hand preference was 7.9%, with very low left-hand use among the 18-22 age group (1%) and high among the 12-15 age group (14%). In the second study (Khartoum, Sudan) 759 undergraduates, ages 18 to 33, answered a 25-item questionnaire. The observed frequency of left manual preference was 5%. Subjects were also asked to indicate any pressure to change hand for writing, eating, or other manual activities and, in the second study, any upper limb injury which temporarily rendered the subject unable to use his (her) preferred hand. Report of an upper limb injury in the past was related to mixed (or inconsistent) hand preference. In both studies, the target activity against left-hand use was eating. These results show that cultural and environmental factors could change "natural" hand preference in three ways: (i) by changing the hand used for only one activity (e.g., eating), with no change for other familiar unimanual activities; (ii) by reducing the degree of hand preference; (iii) by changing the overall preferred hand, generally reducing the prevalence of left-handedness. The design of handedness studies should allow these possibilities to be distinguished.
为了进一步探究文化和环境因素在人类用手偏好中的作用,对来自科特迪瓦和苏丹的学生进行了两项调查。在第一项研究中(科特迪瓦阿比让),382名年龄在12至22岁的中学生回答了一份包含20个项目的用手偏好问卷。观察到的左利手频率为7.9%,在18 - 22岁年龄组中左利手使用率非常低(1%),而在12 - 15岁年龄组中较高(14%)。在第二项研究中(苏丹喀土穆),759名年龄在18至33岁的大学生回答了一份包含25个项目的问卷。观察到的左利手频率为5%。受试者还被要求指出在书写、进食或其他手动活动中是否有改变用手习惯的压力,并且在第二项研究中,要指出是否有上肢损伤曾暂时导致受试者无法使用其偏好的手。过去有上肢损伤的报告与混合(或不一致)用手偏好有关。在两项研究中,反对使用左手的目标活动都是进食。这些结果表明,文化和环境因素可以通过三种方式改变“自然”用手偏好:(i)仅改变用于一项活动(如进食)的手,而其他熟悉的单手活动的用手习惯不变;(ii)降低用手偏好的程度;(iii)改变整体偏好的手,通常会降低左利手的比例。利手研究的设计应能区分这些可能性。