Schaafsma S M, Riedstra B J, Pfannkuche K A, Bouma A, Groothuis T G G
Department of Behavioural Biology, University of Groningen, Haren, The Netherlands.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2009 Apr 12;364(1519):915-27. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2008.0244.
Despite several decades of research, the epigenesis of behavioural and brain lateralization is still elusive, although its knowledge is important in understanding developmental plasticity, function and evolution of lateralization, and its relationship with developmental disorders. Over the last decades, it has become clear that behavioural lateralization is not restricted to humans, but a fundamental principle in the organization of behaviour in vertebrates. This has opened the possibility of extending descriptive studies on human lateralization with descriptive and experimental studies on other vertebrate species. In this review, we therefore explore the evidence for the role of genes and environment on behavioural lateralization in humans and other animals. First, we discuss the predominant genetic models for human handedness, and conclude that their explanatory power alone is not sufficient, leaving, together with ambiguous results from adoption studies and selection experiments in animals, ample opportunity for a role of environmental factors. Next, we discuss the potential influence of such factors, including perinatal asymmetrical perception induced by asymmetrical head position or parental care, and social modulation, both in humans and other vertebrates, presenting some evidence from our own work on the domestic chick. We conclude that both perinatal asymmetrical perception and later social modulation are likely candidates in influencing the degree or strength of lateralization in both humans and other vertebrates. However, in most cases unequivocal evidence for this is lacking and we will point out further avenues for research.
尽管经过了几十年的研究,但行为和大脑偏侧化的表观遗传学仍然难以捉摸,尽管了解它对于理解发育可塑性、偏侧化的功能和进化以及它与发育障碍的关系很重要。在过去几十年里,很明显行为偏侧化并不局限于人类,而是脊椎动物行为组织的一个基本原则。这为通过对其他脊椎动物物种的描述性和实验性研究来扩展对人类偏侧化的描述性研究开辟了可能性。因此,在这篇综述中,我们探讨了基因和环境在人类及其他动物行为偏侧化中作用的证据。首先,我们讨论了人类利手的主要遗传模型,并得出结论,仅靠它们的解释力是不够的,再加上收养研究和动物选择实验的结果不明确,这为环境因素发挥作用留下了充足的空间。接下来,我们讨论这些因素的潜在影响,包括由不对称头部位置或父母照顾引起的围产期不对称感知以及社会调节,这在人类和其他脊椎动物中都有,我们还展示了一些来自我们对家鸡研究的证据。我们得出结论,围产期不对称感知和后期社会调节都可能是影响人类和其他脊椎动物偏侧化程度或强度的因素。然而,在大多数情况下,缺乏对此明确的证据,我们将指出进一步的研究途径。