Ofiara L, Roman T, Schwartzman K, Levy R D
Division of Respiratory Medicine, Royal Victoria Hospital, McGill University, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Chest. 1997 Oct;112(4):946-53. doi: 10.1378/chest.112.4.946.
We evaluated bronchoscopic tumor appearance and tumor location as determinants of response to high-dose rate brachytherapy (HDR-BT) in patients with symptomatic unresectable bronchogenic carcinoma previously treated with external-beam irradiation.
Thirty patients with symptomatic endobronchial bronchogenic carcinoma who had previously completed external irradiation were divided into two groups based on whether the initial bronchoscopic appearance showed an endoluminal mass or submucosal infiltration/extrinsic compression. Furthermore, patients were also classified based on tumor location: central (trachea or mainstem bronchi) and peripheral (lobar or segmental bronchi). Patients underwent three treatments of 800 cGy intraluminal irradiation at 2-week intervals, with follow-up evaluation 4 weeks later. We evaluated response in tumor extent based on bronchoscopic and chest radiograph appearance, as well as symptoms with standardized scales.
Fifteen of 24 patients who underwent follow-up bronchoscopy had reductions in the degree of endobronchial obstruction. Seven of 24 patients had radiographic improvement in the extent of atelectasis. Patients with both tumor appearances (endoluminal and submucosal/extrinsic compression) had significant improvements following HDR-BT with regard to hemoptysis. Patients with submucosal disease also had improvement in cough. Patients with peripheral tumors had better rates of response for hemoptysis and cough than did those with central tumors.
HDR-BT may result in symptomatic improvement in patients with bronchogenic carcinoma, whether characterized endoscopically as endoluminal projection or submucosal infiltration/extrinsic compression. Peripheral tumors have better rates of response than central tumors, possibly on the basis of less extensive disease.
我们评估了支气管镜下肿瘤表现和肿瘤位置,以此作为先前接受外照射治疗的有症状不可切除支气管源性癌患者对高剂量率近距离放疗(HDR - BT)反应的决定因素。
30例有症状的支气管内支气管源性癌患者,他们先前已完成外照射,根据初始支气管镜表现为腔内肿块还是黏膜下浸润/外压分为两组。此外,患者还根据肿瘤位置分类:中央型(气管或主支气管)和周围型(叶支气管或段支气管)。患者每隔2周接受3次800 cGy腔内照射治疗,4周后进行随访评估。我们根据支气管镜和胸部X线片表现以及症状标准量表评估肿瘤范围的反应。
24例接受随访支气管镜检查的患者中有15例支气管内阻塞程度减轻。24例患者中有7例肺不张范围在影像学上有所改善。两种肿瘤表现(腔内和黏膜下/外压)的患者在接受HDR - BT后咯血症状均有显著改善。黏膜下病变的患者咳嗽症状也有所改善。周围型肿瘤患者咯血和咳嗽的反应率高于中央型肿瘤患者。
HDR - BT可能使支气管源性癌患者的症状得到改善,无论内镜下表现为腔内突出还是黏膜下浸润/外压。周围型肿瘤比中央型肿瘤有更好的反应率,可能是因为病变范围较小。