Harris D R, Andrews R, Elixhauser A
Westat, Inc., Rockville, Maryland, USA.
Ethn Dis. 1997 Spring-Summer;7(2):91-105.
A number of studies have found that blacks and females with coronary heart disease are less likely to undergo major diagnostic and therapeutic procedures than whites and males, even after controlling for severity of illness and other indicators of physical condition. This investigation examined 78 conditions treated in acute care hospitals to identify possible variations in medical treatment by race and gender among blacks and whites. The study is unique in examining such a wide range of conditions and in using an all-payer national sample. The study examines over 1.7 million inpatient discharge abstracts from the Hospital Cost and Utilization Project, a national sample of about 500 hospitals in the United States. Logistic regression modeling was used to describe the influence of race and gender among blacks and whites on the likelihood of having a major therapeutic or major diagnostic procedure, controlling for patient age, disease severity, health insurance and hospital-level characteristics. The study found that blacks were less likely than whites to receive major therapeutic procedures in 37 of 77 (48%) conditions, and females were less likely than males to receive major therapeutic procedures for 32 of 62 (52%) conditions. The proportion of conditions in which blacks and females were less likely to receive a major diagnostic procedure (without a major therapeutic procedure) was 21% and 26%, respectively. This study identified a number of conditions with apparent variations in medical treatment by race or gender among blacks and whites that should be targeted for more detailed investigations.
多项研究发现,患有冠心病的黑人和女性比白人和男性接受主要诊断和治疗程序的可能性更小,即便在对疾病严重程度和其他身体状况指标进行控制之后亦是如此。本调查研究了急症医院治疗的78种病症,以确定黑人和白人在医疗方面可能存在的种族和性别差异。该研究的独特之处在于考察了如此广泛的病症范围,并使用了一个涵盖所有付费者的全国样本。该研究考察了来自医院成本与利用项目的170多万份住院出院摘要,该项目是美国约500家医院的全国样本。采用逻辑回归模型来描述黑人和白人中的种族和性别对接受主要治疗或主要诊断程序可能性的影响,并对患者年龄、疾病严重程度、医疗保险和医院层面的特征进行控制。研究发现,在77种病症中的37种(48%)情况下,黑人接受主要治疗程序的可能性低于白人;在62种病症中的32种(52%)情况下,女性接受主要治疗程序的可能性低于男性。黑人和女性接受主要诊断程序(无主要治疗程序)可能性较低的病症比例分别为21%和26%。本研究确定了一些在黑人和白人之间存在明显种族或性别医疗差异的病症,应对这些病症进行更详细的调查。