Hill A, Burge A, Skinner C
Department of Respiratory Medicine, Birmingham Heartlands Hospital, UK.
Thorax. 1997 Nov;52(11):994-7. doi: 10.1136/thx.52.11.994.
This study was designed to assess the current incidence of tuberculosis (TB) in National Health Service hospital staff in the West Midlands region of England and to evaluate the effectiveness of occupational health screening and surveillance procedures.
A four year prospective study (1992-5) was carried out with case ascertainment through occupational health departments and the Midlands Thoracic Society registry of rare respiratory diseases.
No case was known to an occupational health department that was not notified by the registry and, in addition, the registry yielded a further six cases. There were 26 cases of active TB, of which 24 presented with symptoms and 12 had no pre-employment screening. All except one doctor were foreign born--mainly from the Indian subcontinent (ISC)--and of recent UK entry, whilst all except one nurse were white females. The following are annual TB incidences per 10(4) (95% confidence interval): ISC and non-white doctors 17.0 (7.8 to 26.2), not significantly greater than in the local ISC and non-white social class 1 working age population (11.8 (8.5 to 15.1)); white nurses 0.6 (0.2 to 1.0), significantly greater (p < 0.05) than that of white women in the local social class 2 working age population (0.2 (0.1 to 0.3)); others (mortuary attendant, physiotherapist, radiographer and theatre technician) 1.0 (0.02 to 2.0), not significantly greater than in the local social class 2 working age population (0.6 (0.5 to 0.7)).
Case ascertainment via the registry was complete. Most cases of TB were in nurses and doctors, more commonly in doctors. However, all but one of the doctors were foreign born and probably had reactivation of infection acquired abroad rather than infection occupationally acquired in the UK. All but one of the nurses, however, were UK born and may have had occupationally acquired disease, their incidence being higher than in the community. As most cases present with symptoms, there needs to be continued emphasis on prompt reporting of suspicious symptoms both before and during employment, and pre-employment BCG vaccination where appropriate.
本研究旨在评估英国西米德兰兹地区国民医疗服务体系医院工作人员中结核病(TB)的当前发病率,并评估职业健康筛查和监测程序的有效性。
开展了一项为期四年的前瞻性研究(1992 - 1995年),通过职业健康部门和米德兰兹胸腔协会罕见呼吸道疾病登记处确定病例。
职业健康部门知晓的病例无一未被登记处通报,此外,登记处还发现了另外6例病例。共有26例活动性结核病病例,其中24例有症状,12例未进行入职前筛查。除一名医生外,所有病例均出生于国外,主要来自印度次大陆(ISC),且近期进入英国,而除一名护士外,所有护士均为白人女性。以下是每10⁴的年度结核病发病率(95%置信区间):ISC和非白人医生为17.0(7.8至26.2),不比当地ISC和非白人社会阶层1工作年龄人口的发病率(11.8(8.5至15.1))显著更高;白人护士为0.6(0.2至1.0),显著高于当地社会阶层2工作年龄人口中白人女性的发病率(0.2(0.1至0.3))(p < 0.05);其他人员(太平间 attendant、物理治疗师、放射技师和手术室技术员)为1.0(0.02至2.0),不比当地社会阶层2工作年龄人口的发病率(0.6(0.5至0.7))显著更高。
通过登记处确定病例的工作是完整的。大多数结核病病例发生在护士和医生中,更常见于医生。然而,除一名医生外,所有医生均出生于国外,可能是国外感染的再激活,而非在英国职业获得感染。然而,除一名护士外,所有护士均出生于英国,可能患有职业获得性疾病,其发病率高于社区。由于大多数病例有症状,需要继续强调在就业前和就业期间及时报告可疑症状,并在适当情况下进行入职前卡介苗接种。