Meikle S R, Matthews J C, Cunningham V J, Bailey D L, Livieratos L, Jones T, Price P
MRC Cyclotron Unit, Hammersmith Hospital, Royal Postgraduate Medical School, London, UK.
Phys Med Biol. 1998 Mar;43(3):651-66. doi: 10.1088/0031-9155/43/3/016.
Spectral analysis is a general modelling approach that enables calculation of parametric images from reconstructed tracer kinetic data independent of an assumed compartmental structure. We investigated the validity of applying spectral analysis directly to projection data motivated by the advantages that: (i) the number of reconstructions is reduced by an order of magnitude and (ii) iterative reconstruction becomes practical which may improve signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). A dynamic software phantom with typical 2-[11C]thymidine kinetics was used to compare projection-based and image-based methods and to assess bias-variance trade-offs using iterative expectation maximization (EM) reconstruction. We found that the two approaches are not exactly equivalent due to properties of the non-negative least-squares algorithm. However, the differences are small (< 5%) and mainly affect parameters related to early and late time points on the impulse response function (K1 and, to a lesser extent, VD). The optimal number of EM iteration was 15-30 with up to a two-fold improvement in SNR over filtered back projection. We conclude that projection-based spectral analysis with EM reconstruction yields accurate parametric images with high SNR and has potential application to a wide range of positron emission tomography ligands.
频谱分析是一种通用的建模方法,可根据重建的示踪剂动力学数据计算参数图像,而无需假设隔室结构。我们研究了直接将频谱分析应用于投影数据的有效性,其动机在于:(i)重建次数减少了一个数量级,(ii)迭代重建变得可行,这可能会提高信噪比(SNR)。使用具有典型2-[11C]胸苷动力学的动态软件体模来比较基于投影和基于图像的方法,并使用迭代期望最大化(EM)重建来评估偏差-方差权衡。我们发现,由于非负最小二乘算法的特性,这两种方法并不完全等效。然而,差异很小(<5%),主要影响与脉冲响应函数上的早期和晚期时间点相关的参数(K1,以及在较小程度上的VD)。EM迭代的最佳次数为15-30次,与滤波反投影相比,SNR提高了两倍。我们得出结论,基于投影的频谱分析与EM重建可产生具有高SNR的准确参数图像,并具有广泛应用于正电子发射断层扫描配体的潜力。