Olde Rikkert M G, van Asselt D Z, van Kraaij D J, Jansen R W, Hoefnagels W H
Afdeling Geriatrie, Academisch Ziekenhuis Nijmegen, St. Radboud.
Tijdschr Gerontol Geriatr. 1998 Feb;29(1):4-10.
The conduct of research in geriatric medicine differs from that in other medical specialties in a number of ways. In geriatric research it is almost impossible to study a large, homogeneous group of subjects, suffering solely from the problem to be studied. Moreover, measurements and questionnaires should be short, simple and not very troublesome. These differences are due to the heterogeneity of geriatric patients and the high prevalence of multimorbidity, often resulting in impaired physical, psychological and social performance. In this article a number of issues which are important for successful recruitment and selection of subjects for geriatric research are discussed. First, a review of relevant literature is given, and subsequently, experiences concerning recruitment and selection appreciated in the Nijmegen geriatric research programme' are described. This programme was part of the governmental Netherlands Programme for Research on Ageing (NESTOR). According to the literature the efficacy of recruitment may be improved by: personal contact between researcher and subject in view, introduction of the selection criteria already at the time of subjects' recruitment, a balance between research burden and profit, sufficient rewards for participation, both financially and non-financially, maximal effort in the subjects' transport, and also piloting of the recruitment procedure. In the NESTOR-studies the average number of subjects who were recruited and who completed the studies was low (23%), because a lot of the recruited subjects did not meet the selection criteria or considered participation as too troublesome. Subjects who agreed to participate showed high research compliance.
老年医学研究的开展在许多方面不同于其他医学专科。在老年医学研究中,几乎不可能研究仅患有待研究问题的大量、同质的受试者群体。此外,测量和问卷应该简短、简单且不太麻烦。这些差异是由于老年患者的异质性和多种疾病的高患病率,这常常导致身体、心理和社会功能受损。本文讨论了一些对于成功招募和选择老年医学研究受试者很重要的问题。首先,给出了相关文献综述,随后描述了在奈梅亨老年医学研究项目中对招募和选择的体会。该项目是荷兰政府老龄化研究项目(NESTOR)的一部分。根据文献,招募的效果可以通过以下方式提高:研究人员与受试者进行面对面的个人接触,在招募受试者时就介绍选择标准,平衡研究负担和收益,为参与提供足够的经济和非经济奖励,在受试者交通方面尽最大努力,以及对招募程序进行试点。在NESTOR研究中,招募并完成研究的受试者平均数量较低(23%),因为许多招募的受试者不符合选择标准或认为参与太麻烦。同意参与的受试者表现出很高的研究依从性。