Rubin B P, Hasserjian R P, Singer S, Janecka I, Fletcher J A, Fletcher C D
Department of Pathology, Harvard Medical School, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Am J Surg Pathol. 1998 Apr;22(4):459-64. doi: 10.1097/00000478-199804000-00011.
Spindle cell rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS) is a recently described variant of embryonal RMS that carries a relatively favorable prognosis when compared with other forms of RMS. To date, spindle cell RMS has been described only in children. The authors have identified two unusual cases occurring in adults using the following criteria: tumors composed mainly of fascicular, relatively monomorphic spindle-shaped cells that show unequivocal immunohistochemical and ultrastructural evidence of myogenic differentiation. The tumors were identified in a 38-year-old woman and a 56-year-old man, arising in the cheek and left hemidiaphragm, respectively. Both were treated with surgical resection and chemotherapy. The first patient died of uncontrolled local recurrence of her tumor at 27 months after diagnosis, and the second died of metastatic disease at 13 months follow-up. The tumors were composed mainly of fascicles of spindle cells with palely eosinophilic cytoplasm admixed diffusely with sparse polygonal, rounded, or strap-shaped rhabdomyoblasts with brightly eosinophilic cytoplasm and with cross-striations in the first case only. Immunostaining for muscle-related antigens showed staining for smooth-muscle actin (focal), pan-actin HHF-35, desmin, fast myosin, myoglobin, and MyoD1. Both cases were negative for S-100 protein. On electron microscopy, both cases showed neoplastic rhabdomyoblasts with clear-cut sarcomeric differentiation in many of the tumor cells. Spindle cell RMS poses special problems in differential diagnosis when arising in adults and should be distinguished from leiomyosarcoma, malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor with heterologous rhabdomyoblastic differentiation (malignant Triton tumor), and fibrosarcoma. In view of the good prognosis afforded children with spindle cell RMS and in light of the chemoresponsive behavior of RMS in general, we feel that it is important to identify tumors that meet the criteria for spindle cell RMS occurring in the adult population. However, based on these two cases, it is possible that spindle cell RMS occurring in adults may not be associated with such a favorable outcome.
梭形细胞横纹肌肉瘤(RMS)是一种最近被描述的胚胎性RMS变体,与其他形式的RMS相比,其预后相对较好。迄今为止,梭形细胞RMS仅在儿童中被描述过。作者使用以下标准确定了两例发生在成人中的不寻常病例:肿瘤主要由束状、相对单一形态的梭形细胞组成,这些细胞显示出明确的免疫组化和超微结构证据表明有肌源性分化。肿瘤分别在一名38岁女性的脸颊和一名56岁男性的左半膈肌中被发现。两人均接受了手术切除和化疗。第一名患者在诊断后27个月死于肿瘤无法控制的局部复发,第二名患者在随访13个月时死于转移性疾病。肿瘤主要由梭形细胞束组成,细胞质淡嗜酸性,弥漫性地与稀疏的多边形、圆形或带状横纹肌母细胞混合,后者细胞质亮嗜酸性,仅在第一例中有横纹。肌肉相关抗原的免疫染色显示平滑肌肌动蛋白(局灶性)、泛肌动蛋白HHF-35、结蛋白、快肌球蛋白、肌红蛋白和MyoD1染色阳性。两例S-100蛋白均为阴性。电子显微镜检查显示,两例在许多肿瘤细胞中均有明确的肌节分化的肿瘤性横纹肌母细胞。梭形细胞RMS在成人中发生时在鉴别诊断中存在特殊问题,应与平滑肌肉瘤、具有异源性横纹肌母细胞分化的恶性外周神经鞘瘤(恶性蝾螈瘤)和纤维肉瘤相鉴别。鉴于儿童梭形细胞RMS预后良好,且鉴于RMS总体上对化疗有反应,我们认为识别符合成人人群中梭形细胞RMS标准的肿瘤很重要。然而,基于这两例病例,成人中发生的梭形细胞RMS可能与如此良好的结果无关。