Mouchet J
ORSTOM, Paris.
Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 1998;91(1):64-6.
The Highlands of Madagascar were malaria free until 1878, when a severe epidemic occurred, following the development of irrigated rice farming. Then, the disease became endemic. Between 1949 and 1962, malaria was "eradicated" on the Highlands by joint house spraying and chemoprophylaxis measures. The main vector An. funestus disappeared. In 1986-1988, a very severe epidemic with high lethality rate devastated the Highlands. It is now under control. Thanks to the data of a religious dispensary, we could follow the evolution of malaria on the Highlands from 1971 to 1995. The number of cases begin to grow in 1975 when the surveillance was neglected. A second step was observed in 1979, when chemoprophylaxis/chemotherapy centres were closed. Then, the increase of malaria became exponential up to 1988. At the time, the prevalence had became similar to that of 1948, before the eradication. The epidemic is not due to global warming because the temperature has been stable for the last 30 years. The malaria rise was due the cancellation of control measures. When control was reactivated, the epidemic ceased. In Swaziland, Zimbabwe and South Africa, malaria epidemics were also due to control failure. In Uganda Highlands, above 1500 m, malaria rise seems linked to the environmental changes, e.g. the cultures which replace papyrus swamp in the valley. But malaria did not overcame the altitude of 1900 which it had already reached in 1960. Rainfall should also be considered as a key factor in the epidemics. In the Sahel West Africa, temperature increased from 0.5 degree C to 01 degree C degree in the last 25 years, but rainfall decreased from 30%. As a result, one of the vector, Anopheles funestus disappeared and malaria prevalence dropped by 60 to 80%. It is not acceptable to predict the future evolution of malaria in taking in account only one parameter: the temperature. The whole factors involved in the epidemiology should be taken into account. The predictions based only on the temperature increase (global warming) can be totally wrong if the rainfall, for example, decreases.
直到1878年,马达加斯加高地一直没有疟疾。当时,随着灌溉水稻种植的发展,一场严重的流行病爆发,随后这种疾病成为地方病。1949年至1962年间,通过联合室内喷洒和化学预防措施,高地的疟疾被“根除”,主要病媒——险恶按蚊消失了。1986年至1988年,一场致死率很高的非常严重的流行病肆虐高地,目前疫情已得到控制。多亏了一家宗教诊疗所的数据,我们得以追踪1971年至1995年高地疟疾的发展情况。1975年,当监测工作被忽视时,病例数量开始增加。1979年出现了第二个阶段,当时化学预防/化疗中心关闭,随后,疟疾的增长呈指数级,一直持续到1988年。那时,患病率已与1948年根除之前的患病率相似。这场流行病并非由全球变暖导致,因为过去30年温度一直稳定。疟疾的增加是由于控制措施的取消,当重新启动控制措施时,疫情停止。在斯威士兰、津巴布韦和南非,疟疾疫情也是由于控制不力。在乌干达高地海拔1500米以上地区,疟疾的增加似乎与环境变化有关,例如山谷中取代纸莎草沼泽的作物,但疟疾并未突破1960年已达到的1900米海拔高度。降雨也应被视为疫情的一个关键因素。在西非萨赫勒地区,过去25年温度从0.5摄氏度上升到1摄氏度,但降雨量减少了30%。结果,病媒之一——险恶按蚊消失,疟疾患病率下降了60%至80%。仅考虑一个参数——温度来预测疟疾的未来发展是不可接受的,应该考虑流行病学中涉及的所有因素。例如,如果降雨量减少,仅基于温度升高(全球变暖)的预测可能会完全错误。