Brown J J, Wells G A, Trottier A J, Bonneau J, Ferris B
Department of Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 1998 Apr 1;23(7):821-7. doi: 10.1097/00007632-199804010-00017.
A survey of a random sample of 1002 members of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police to determine their experience with low back pain.
To determine the prevalence of low back pain among Royal Canadian Mounted Police members and to assess the validity of the perception that the patrol car seat and the duty belt are causing a higher rate of low back pain among members of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police than in the general population.
Low back pain is a common problem throughout the industrialized world, with reported 1-year prevalence rates between 25% and 62%. Prevalence of low back pain among people who drive motor vehicles for a significant part of the day appears higher than in the general population. Among police officers, 1-year prevalence rates of between 44% and 62% have been reported.
A computerized database of 14,897 serving regular members was used to identify a sample of officers on active duty. A low back pain questionnaire was mailed to each selected member, eliciting information regarding their experience with low back pain, their exposure to known and putative risk factors, and their opinions about the contribution of these potential risk factors. The respondents to the questionnaire remained anonymous.
The response rate was 80%. The prevalence of "chronic or recurring low back pain since joining the force" was 54.9%, which is comparable with the lifetime prevalence reported for the general population. Of those who reported having back problems, only 8.5% had such problems before joining the force. Seventy-six percent who had low back pain reported having a problem within the last year, giving an overall 1-year prevalence of 41.8%, which is comparable with that for the general population. The a priori assumption that driving or wearing a duty belt contributed to the problem was shared by most police officers surveyed. However, only about half of the members who replied drove for more than half the working day or wore the duty belt. These members had the same prevalence of low back pain as those who did not drive or wear the duty belt.
The prevalence of low back pain in this police force is comparable with that in the general population, and driving a patrol car or wearing the duty belt does not appear to influence the prevalence rate in this population.
对1002名加拿大皇家骑警成员进行随机抽样调查,以确定他们的腰痛经历。
确定加拿大皇家骑警成员中腰痛的患病率,并评估关于巡逻车座椅和执勤腰带导致加拿大皇家骑警成员腰痛发生率高于普通人群这一认知的有效性。
腰痛是工业化国家普遍存在的问题,据报道1年患病率在25%至62%之间。一天中大部分时间驾驶机动车的人群中腰痛患病率似乎高于普通人群。在警察中,据报道1年患病率在44%至62%之间。
使用一个包含14897名在职正式成员的计算机化数据库来确定现役警官样本。向每位选定成员邮寄一份腰痛问卷,获取有关他们腰痛经历、接触已知和假定风险因素的信息,以及他们对这些潜在风险因素作用的看法。问卷受访者保持匿名。
回复率为80%。“加入警队后慢性或复发性腰痛”的患病率为54.9%,与普通人群报告的终生患病率相当。在报告有背部问题的人中,只有8.5%在加入警队前就有此类问题。76%有腰痛的人报告在过去一年有问题,总体1年患病率为41.8%,与普通人群相当。大多数接受调查的警察都认同开车或佩戴执勤腰带会导致问题这一先验假设。然而,只有约一半回复的成员工作日开车时间超过一半或佩戴执勤腰带。这些成员的腰痛患病率与不开车或不佩戴执勤腰带的成员相同。
这支警察部队中腰痛的患病率与普通人群相当,驾驶巡逻车或佩戴执勤腰带似乎不会影响该人群的患病率。