Romani C, Calabrese A
School of Psychology, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, UK.
Brain Lang. 1998 Aug;64(1):83-121. doi: 10.1006/brln.1998.1958.
The Sonority Dispersion Principle (Clements, 1990) states that the sharper the rise in sonority between the beginning of the syllable and the nucleus, the better the syllable. So far evidence in favour of this principle has been derived mainly from the distributional properties of syllable types and, to a lesser extent, from language acquisition. The case of DB, presented in this study, provides strong evidence that the Sonority Dispersion Principle also applies to an explanation of aphasic errors and revives Jakobson's idea that the same principles of complexity can explain the distribution of syllables, language acquisition, and language loss (Jakobson, 1941, 1968). Although some evidence that sonority constraints aphasic errors has been presented before, this is the first study reporting systematic effects of sonority-based complexity in aphasia.
响度分散原则(克莱门茨,1990)指出,音节开头到核心音之间响度上升越急剧,音节就越好。到目前为止,支持这一原则的证据主要来自音节类型的分布特性,在较小程度上来自语言习得。本研究中呈现的DB案例提供了有力证据,表明响度分散原则也适用于对失语症错误的解释,并复兴了雅各布森的观点,即相同的复杂性原则可以解释音节的分布、语言习得和语言丧失(雅各布森,1941年,1968年)。尽管之前已经有一些关于响度限制失语症错误的证据,但这是第一项报告基于响度的复杂性在失语症中具有系统性影响的研究。