Bornstein M H, Haynes O M
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD 20892-2030, USA.
Child Dev. 1998 Jun;69(3):654-71.
We systematically examined relations among 6 measures of child language derived from 3 sources, including observations of the child's speech with mother, experimenter assessments, and maternal reports. A total of 184 20-month-olds and their mothers contributed complete information about child language comprehension and expression. Correlations of child language measures with socioeconomic status and maternal education were accounted for, as were correlations of child language measures with mothers' verbal intelligence, maternal report measures with mothers' tendency to respond in a socially desirable fashion, and experimenter assessments with child social competence. Structural equation modeling supported (1) strong relations among child language measures derived from observations of the child's speech with mother, experimenter assessments, and maternal reports; (2) the loading of multiple measures of child language from different sources on a single latent construct of vocabulary competence; and (3) the predictive validity of the vocabulary competence latent variable at 20 months, as well as receptive vocabulary specifically, for both verbal and performance IQ (verbal better than performance) at 48 months. Neither an index of child monologing (a nonvocabulary language measure) nor symbolic play (a nonlinguistic representational measure) covaried with vocabulary competence. Girls consistently outperformed boys on individual language measures, but no differences emerged in any model in the fit for boys and girls.
我们系统地研究了源自3种来源的6种儿童语言测量指标之间的关系,这些来源包括对儿童与母亲对话的观察、实验者评估以及母亲报告。共有184名20个月大的幼儿及其母亲提供了有关儿童语言理解和表达的完整信息。我们考虑了儿童语言测量指标与社会经济地位和母亲教育程度之间的相关性,以及儿童语言测量指标与母亲言语智力之间的相关性、母亲报告测量指标与母亲以社会期望方式回应的倾向之间的相关性,还有实验者评估与儿童社会能力之间的相关性。结构方程模型支持:(1)源自对儿童与母亲对话的观察、实验者评估以及母亲报告的儿童语言测量指标之间存在强关系;(2)来自不同来源的多种儿童语言测量指标在词汇能力这一单一潜在结构上的负荷;(3)20个月时词汇能力潜在变量的预测效度,特别是接受性词汇对48个月时言语智商和操作智商(言语智商优于操作智商)的预测效度。儿童独白指标(一种非词汇语言测量指标)和象征性游戏(一种非语言表征测量指标)均与词汇能力不相关。在各项语言测量指标上,女孩始终比男孩表现更好,但在任何模型中,男孩和女孩的拟合度均未出现差异。