Salmaso S, Mastrantonio P, Wassilak S G, Giuliano M, Anemona A, Giammanco A, Tozzi A E, Ciofi degli Atti M L, Greco D
Laboratory of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Rome, Italy.
Vaccine. 1998 Aug;16(13):1270-5. doi: 10.1016/s0264-410x(98)00040-1.
A large, randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trial in Italy on two three-component pertussis vaccines, given as DTaP in infancy, one manufactured by SmithKline and Beecham (SB) and one by Chiron Biocine (CB), found each vaccine to be 84% efficacious through the average age of 24 months. The cohort of children enrolled in the trial was followed with unmodified case ascertainment procedures for nine additional calendar months, during which partial unblinding occurred, for the unvaccinated randomized group. For the DTaP groups, the specific vaccine assignment remained double-blinded throughout the entire additional observation period. Pertussis was defined as paroxysmal cough lasting at least 21 days and confirmed by culture or serology. In the additional 9 months the observed absolute efficacy was 78% (95% CI, 62-87%) for SB DTaP vaccine and 89% (95% CI, 79-94%) for CB DTaP. The relative risk of developing pertussis in SB DTaP recipients compared to CB DTaP vaccinees was 1.99 (95% CI, 1.13-3.51). By combining observations from the initial and additional follow-up periods, the overall observed vaccine efficacy through an average age of 33 months of SB DTaP was 80% and of CB DTaP, 85%.
在意大利进行的一项大型随机安慰剂对照临床试验中,对两种用于婴儿期的三联百日咳疫苗(白百破疫苗)进行了研究,一种由史克必成公司(SB)生产,另一种由奇隆生物制药公司(CB)生产,结果发现每种疫苗在24个月的平均年龄时有效率均为84%。对参与试验的儿童队列采用未修改的病例确定程序进行了另外9个日历月的随访,在此期间,未接种疫苗的随机分组组出现了部分揭盲情况。对于白百破疫苗组,在整个额外观察期内,具体的疫苗分配情况一直保持双盲。百日咳定义为阵发性咳嗽持续至少21天,并经培养或血清学确诊。在额外的9个月中,观察到SB白百破疫苗的绝对有效率为78%(95%可信区间,62 - 87%),CB白百破疫苗的绝对有效率为89%(95%可信区间,79 - 94%)。与CB白百破疫苗接种者相比,SB白百破疫苗接种者患百日咳的相对风险为1.99(95%可信区间,1.13 - 3.51)。通过结合初始随访期和额外随访期的观察结果,在平均年龄33个月时,SB白百破疫苗的总体观察到的疫苗有效率为80%;CB白百破疫苗为85%。