Engebretson J
School of Nursing, University of Texas-Houston Health Science Center, USA.
Altern Ther Health Med. 1998 Mar;4(2):37-43.
A heterodox model of healing incorporating the basic dualism of Western philosophy--the world of concrete material substance versus that of thought, ideals, and spirit--is proposed. Such dualism is reflected in Western constructions of healing. An explanatory paradigm model with a horizontal axis representing paradigms of healing from positivism to metaphysics and a vertical axis representing activities of healing from the material to the spiritual was derived from ethnographic work with healers. A health practice model following the same philosophical patterns illustrates reflected American cultural values in the relative positioning of healing modalities from the orthodox biomedical to the most metaphysical or alternative. Examples of specific modalities of healing, many of which are resurfacing with increasing public interest in alternative therapies, are illustrated. This model places biomedicine in the same context as other philosophical approaches to healing as a standard for comparison. Implications for practice and research are discussed.
提出了一种非正统的治疗模型,该模型融合了西方哲学的基本二元论——具体物质实体的世界与思想、理想和精神的世界。这种二元论反映在西方的治疗观念中。通过对治疗师的人种志研究,得出了一个解释性范式模型,其横轴代表从实证主义到形而上学的治疗范式,纵轴代表从物质到精神的治疗活动。一个遵循相同哲学模式的健康实践模型说明了美国文化价值观在从正统生物医学到最形而上学或替代疗法的治疗方式相对定位中的体现。文中列举了具体治疗方式的例子,其中许多随着公众对替代疗法兴趣的增加而重新出现。该模型将生物医学与其他治疗哲学方法置于同一背景下作为比较标准。并讨论了对实践和研究的启示。