Maubon A J, Pothin A, Ferru J M, Berger V M, Daurès J P, Rouanet J P
Department of Medical Imaging, Centre Medico Chirurgical Beausoleil, Montpellier, France.
Radiology. 1998 Sep;208(3):671-8. doi: 10.1148/radiology.208.3.9722844.
To compare the diagnostic values of three T2-weighted sequences in unselected brain 0.5-T magnetic resonance (MR) imaging examinations.
MR imaging was performed in 102 patients because of neurologic symptoms or the follow up "previously known disease." The protocol comprised three T2-weighted sequences: turbo spin-echo (SE), turbo fluid-attenuated inversion-recovery (FLAIR), and gradient and SE (GRASE) sequences. In a prospective, blinded analysis, sequences were compared quantitatively and qualitative by three independent readers for lesion detection and characterization.
Twenty-four patients had normal findings, and 78 had abnormal findings, with 121 final diagnoses. Quantitatively, the "white" cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) sequences, turbo SE and GRASE, had higher contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) than the "black" CSF sequence, FLAIR, with respect to the signal intensity of white manner, but lower CNRs than FLAIR with respect to the signal intensity of CSF. Qualitatively, for lesion detection, sensitivity and accuracy were significantly higher for FLAIR than for turbo SE or GRASE (P < .05); there was no statistically significant difference between turbo SE or GRASE. FOR lesion characterization, FLAIR was significantly superior to GRASE and turbo SE for white matter disease (P < .05), superior to only turbo SE (P < .05) for vascular disease, and not superior to GRASE or turbo SE for tumors.
The black CSF T2-weighted turbo FLAIR sequence is a useful adjunct to the usual white CSF T2-weighted sequences in unselected brain 0.5-T MR imaging.
比较三种T2加权序列在未经选择的脑部0.5-T磁共振(MR)成像检查中的诊断价值。
对102例因神经系统症状或“既往已知疾病”随访而进行MR成像检查的患者进行研究。检查方案包括三种T2加权序列:快速自旋回波(SE)、快速液体衰减反转恢复(FLAIR)和梯度回波与SE(GRASE)序列。在一项前瞻性、盲法分析中,由三位独立阅片者对序列进行定量和定性比较,以检测和鉴别病变。
24例患者检查结果正常,78例异常,最终诊断121例。在定量方面,“白色”脑脊液(CSF)序列,即快速SE和GRASE序列,相对于白质信号强度,其对比噪声比(CNR)高于“黑色”CSF序列FLAIR,但相对于CSF信号强度,其CNR低于FLAIR。在定性方面,对于病变检测,FLAIR的灵敏度和准确性显著高于快速SE或GRASE(P <.05);快速SE和GRASE之间无统计学显著差异。对于病变鉴别,FLAIR在鉴别白质疾病方面显著优于GRASE和快速SE(P <.05),在鉴别血管疾病方面仅优于快速SE(P <.05),在鉴别肿瘤方面不优于GRASE或快速SE。
在未经选择的脑部0.5-T MR成像中,黑色CSF T2加权快速FLAIR序列是常用的白色CSF T2加权序列的有用辅助序列。