Patel M R, Klufas R A, Shapiro A W
Department of Radiology, Beth Israel Hospital, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1995 Oct;165(4):963-6. doi: 10.2214/ajr.165.4.7677002.
The purpose of this study was to compare a combined gradient and spin-echo (GRASE) technique, which is a rapid T2-weighted imaging sequence, with conventional spin-echo (SE) sequences for imaging brain lesions. The GRASE sequences would allow increased patient throughput with potential cost savings and be useful in uncooperative patients without requiring echoplanar imaging techniques and specialized hardware.
Conventional SE and GRASE T2-weighted images of 49 consecutive patients (20-86 years old) were reviewed independently by three neurora-diologists for the presence and characterization of lesions (most of which were nonspecific foci of hyperintensity within the white matter), gray-white matter differentiation, conspicuity of lesions, and periventricular signal abnormality. The MR studies were performed on a 1.0-T Siemens Magnetom Impact scanner, with the SE images obtained using a TR/TE of 2400/40 and the GRASE images obtained using a TR/effective TE of 4400/110.
The number of lesions detected that were 5 mm or larger in maximal diameter did not significantly differ among techniques. For lesions smaller than 5 mm, conventional SE T2-weighted images showed more lesions (p < .01). The SE images were better than the GRASE images for assessing gray-white matter differentiation, conspicuity of lesions, and periventricular signal abnormality. The two hypointense lesions were better assessed on the conventional SE images.
Although GRASE imaging may be potentially useful for rapid imaging of the brain, our experience shows it has a markedly diminished sensitivity for detecting lesions smaller than 5 mm in diameter. Currently, GRASE imaging should not replace the routine clinical use of conventional SE sequences.
本研究旨在比较一种联合梯度与自旋回波(GRASE)技术(一种快速T2加权成像序列)与传统自旋回波(SE)序列用于脑病变成像的效果。GRASE序列可提高患者通量并可能节省成本,且对不合作患者有用,无需回波平面成像技术和专门硬件。
三位神经放射科医生独立回顾了49例连续患者(年龄20 - 86岁)的传统SE和GRASE T2加权图像,以观察病变的存在与特征(其中大多数为白质内非特异性高信号灶)、灰白质区分、病变清晰度及脑室周围信号异常情况。MR研究在一台1.0-T西门子Magnetom Impact扫描仪上进行,SE图像采用TR/TE为2400/40获得,GRASE图像采用TR/有效TE为4400/110获得。
最大直径5mm或更大的病变检出数量在不同技术之间无显著差异。对于小于5mm的病变,传统SE T2加权图像显示出更多病变(p <.01)。在评估灰白质区分、病变清晰度及脑室周围信号异常方面,SE图像优于GRASE图像。两个低信号病变在传统SE图像上评估更佳。
尽管GRASE成像可能对脑部快速成像有潜在用途,但我们的经验表明,其对检测直径小于5mm的病变敏感性明显降低。目前,GRASE成像不应取代传统SE序列的常规临床应用。