Melhem E R, Bert R J, Walker R E
Department of Radiology, Boston University Medical Center, MA 02118, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1998 Sep;171(3):803-7. doi: 10.2214/ajr.171.3.9725320.
The purpose of this study was to compare the contrast enhancement of lesions of the brain revealed by gadolinium-enhanced optimized fast fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) MR imaging with that of lesions on gadolinium-enhanced optimized T1-weighted spin-echo MR imaging.
Using computer simulations, we optimized the fast FLAIR parameters (TR, TEeff, and inversion time) and the T1-weighted spin-echo parameters (TR and TE) to provide maximum difference in signal intensity between enhancing lesions of the brain and white matter. Seventy-six consecutive patients referred for single-dose gadolinium-enhanced MR imaging of the brain underwent both optimized techniques, which were matched for spatial resolution, bandwidth, and number of excitations. The gadolinium-enhanced fast FLAIR and T -weighted spin-echo MR images were evaluated independently by two observers for number and size of enhancing lesions and for the degree of gray-white matter differentiation. Contrast-to-noise ratios were measured for enhancing lesions 1.0 cm or larger in diameter using 8 x 8 pixel regions of interest in the enhancing lesions and normal white matter.
The most revealing parameters for fast FLAIR MR imaging proved to be a TR of 1500 msec, an inversion time of 683 msec, and a TEeff of 16 msec. For T1-weighted spin-echo MR imaging, the optimized parameters were a TR of 550 msec and a TE of 16 msec. In 28 patients, we saw enhancing lesions of the brain with at least one MR imaging technique. More lesions were seen on the T1-weighted spin-echo sequence (n = 141) than on the fast FLAIR sequence (n = 94) (p < .03). Gray-white matter differentiation was significantly better on the fast FLAIR sequence (p < .001). Contrast-to-noise ratios of enhancing lesions were greater on the T1-weighted spin-echo sequence (p < .001).
In this study, optimized gadolinium-enhanced conventional T1-weighted spin-echo MR imaging proved superior to gadolinium-enhanced fast FLAIR MR imaging in revealing lesions of the brain.
本研究旨在比较钆增强优化快速液体衰减反转恢复(FLAIR)磁共振成像(MR成像)所显示的脑内病变的对比增强情况与钆增强优化T1加权自旋回波MR成像所显示病变的对比增强情况。
通过计算机模拟,我们优化了快速FLAIR参数(TR、有效TE和反转时间)以及T1加权自旋回波参数(TR和TE),以在脑内强化病变与白质之间提供最大的信号强度差异。76例连续接受单次剂量钆增强脑MR成像检查病人均接受了这两种优化技术检查,这两种技术在空间分辨率、带宽和激励次数方面相互匹配。钆增强快速FLAIR和T加权自旋回波MR图像由两名观察者独立评估,以观察强化病变的数量和大小以及灰白质分化程度。使用增强病变和正常白质中8×8像素感兴趣区,对直径1.0厘米或更大的强化病变测量对比噪声比。
快速FLAIR MR成像最具显示效果的参数为TR 1500毫秒、反转时间683毫秒和有效TE 16毫秒。对于T1加权自旋回波MR成像,优化参数为TR 550毫秒和TE 16毫秒。在28例患者中,我们通过至少一种MR成像技术观察到脑内有强化病变。T1加权自旋回波序列上看到的病变(n = 141)比快速FLAIR序列上看到的病变(n = 94)更多(p < 0.03)。快速FLAIR序列上的灰白质分化明显更好(p < 0.001)。T1加权自旋回波序列上强化病变的对比噪声比更高(p < 0.001)。
在本研究中,优化后的钆增强传统T1加权自旋回波MR成像在显示脑内病变方面优于钆增强快速FLAIR MR成像。